Forum Settings
Forums

Add J/K/C - live adapted dramas based on anime.

New
Add live action adaptions whose source was anime like attack on titan live action movie
6 hours ago
#1

Offline
Jan 2014
188
Live action adaptions like attack on titan that was based on anime should be added to the website.Why? Because anime allready have manga or light novel connected to it and adding live action adaptions wouldn't be much different especially if it comes from three main countries japan/korea/china whose anime adaption we allready have.
Wolfyrinn6 hours ago
6 hours ago
#2

Offline
Oct 2010
21681
true, add shingeki movie, it was even better than mappa adaptation

5 hours ago
#3

Offline
Jan 2014
188
Reply to Catalano
true, add shingeki movie, it was even better than mappa adaptation

@Catalano Yes we need the great shingeki move that was created - mappa is not even close.I also think about moderators and their work and how much time it would take for them to add this.It would be surprisingly easily considering there is barely a few live action adaptions that was made so far.
5 hours ago
#4
Offline
Mar 2021
62
Some guys are arguing about whether all Donghuas and Aenis should be deleted, and now others are suggesting adding live-action dramas. I love this website.

Now, seriously speaking, I’d personally prefer if MAL stuck to animation only. Besides, there’s already another website called MyDramaList.
5 hours ago
#5
Offline
Feb 2025
431
EonRed said:
Now, seriously speaking, I’d personally prefer if MAL stuck to animation only.

Would that also mean removing Manga from the site? (I'm indifferent, just curious)
5 hours ago
#6

Online
Aug 2021
4432
Live action is already a little too far in my mere opinion, but if that happens, don't forget to add Death Note drama and Battle Royale.

5 hours ago
#7

Online
Oct 2022
2515
This is an anime forum. We watch anime. We like anime. Thank you for your time.
5 hours ago
#8
Offline
Mar 2021
62
Reply to valico
EonRed said:
Now, seriously speaking, I’d personally prefer if MAL stuck to animation only.

Would that also mean removing Manga from the site? (I'm indifferent, just curious)
@valico Not at all, I was only referring to audiovisual stuff (I should’ve worded my post better).
5 hours ago
#9
Offline
Jun 2022
275
many people don't realize how many great live action adaptations based on the manga are there like for example gintama, kingdom, ruroni kenshin, golden kamuy, one piece, sailor moon and more that has been insanely well recieved in Japan. And there are many more live action adaptations based on the manga that are great also not every manga can and should be adapted to animation but what can be adapted to perfectly is in to live action tv show for example something like vagabond directed in Akira Kurosawa style would be perfection or something like vinland saga I believe could have been even better in live action and the journey of thorfinn in a live action would be even more authentic or berserk can be perfection in live action. And also those manga grounded in realism or being photorealistic can be also perfect in live action.
5 hours ago

Offline
Feb 2023
784
How can we make this clearer? This website is called My ANIME List. This website should only list anime and manga.
4 hours ago

Offline
Jan 2014
188
Reply to ForgotEyeWasHere
How can we make this clearer? This website is called My ANIME List. This website should only list anime and manga.
@ForgotEyeWasHere why have manga ? this website isn't called MyAnimeAndMangaList if we go word by word it should only have anime and list forum should be deleted to as it's not called MyAnimeAndForumList :)
4 hours ago

Offline
Jan 2014
188
Reply to SuperAdventure
This is an anime forum. We watch anime. We like anime. Thank you for your time.
@SuperAdventure we like real action anime adaptions.
4 hours ago

Offline
Jan 2014
188
Reply to jacobPOL
many people don't realize how many great live action adaptations based on the manga are there like for example gintama, kingdom, ruroni kenshin, golden kamuy, one piece, sailor moon and more that has been insanely well recieved in Japan. And there are many more live action adaptations based on the manga that are great also not every manga can and should be adapted to animation but what can be adapted to perfectly is in to live action tv show for example something like vagabond directed in Akira Kurosawa style would be perfection or something like vinland saga I believe could have been even better in live action and the journey of thorfinn in a live action would be even more authentic or berserk can be perfection in live action. And also those manga grounded in realism or being photorealistic can be also perfect in live action.
@jacobPOL you are absolutely right some of live action adaptions is very good.

More topics from this board

Poll: » Should Isekai really be that hated? ( 1 2 3 )

Matt6616 - Aug 4

101 by Matt6616 »»
5 minutes ago

Poll: » Remove all donghua from the site ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

MYZIC - Aug 3

329 by animationBuff »»
29 minutes ago

» Is it unhealthy to treat anime as more than just animation? ( 1 2 )

thewiru - Yesterday

53 by Geark77 »»
36 minutes ago

» Are hardcore anime fans who don't learn Japanese just lazy or stupid? ( 1 2 3 4 )

qasdrtfgbhtghnm - Aug 2

152 by Rally- »»
39 minutes ago

» Do memes about an anime ruin the experience?

EonRed - Aug 5

37 by ryan77999 »»
47 minutes ago
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login