| Thanks @shadroxx2810 and @Chione for hosting the game. I apologize for not able to be there for the game, I had something come up for me in real life that I was unable to give this game my attention. In terms of game balancing complaints/roles, you may direct this to me especially since I was more involved in this area. |
 |
| @Lord_Sithis Just consider this experience. When your in a situation with a unknown third party around & there are only 3 people left. Lynch the third party. To be honest, so long as you did what I did with my shop purchase(right at night start buy) you were basically un touchable. Even if Karote was scum if they attacked you they would just die instead. Same goes for Gwen here which is why I don't entirely agree with the end result. |
  |
| @shadroxx2810 invite me to scum club please |
 |
SightlessReality said: @Lord_Sithis Just consider this experience. When your in a situation with a unknown third party around & there are only 3 people left. Lynch the third party. To be honest, so long as you did what I did with my shop purchase(right at night start buy) you were basically un touchable. Even if Karote was scum if they attacked you they would just die instead. Same goes for Gwen here which is why I don't entirely agree with the end result. I already had a second window open to message shad immediately when the shop opens :P If I wouldnt have got the paralyze potion, I would have just killed Karote and buy the 50% accuracy potion, but pretty sure I would have gotten the paralyze potion..because Sithis was confused as hell and Karote wasnt there x) Next phase could have been fun I guess |
| <3 |
| @shadroxx2810 invite me to scum club as well please. |
|
SightlessReality said: i dont understand what you didnt agree on? Also Karote as scum would abstain from killing for him to waste the item and the game would drag even longer xDDLord_Sithis Just consider this experience. When your in a situation with a unknown third party around & there are only 3 people left. Lynch the third party. To be honest, so long as you did what I did with my shop purchase(right at night start buy) you were basically un touchable. Even if Karote was scum if they attacked you they would just die instead. Same goes for Gwen here which is why I don't entirely agree with the end result. Also, shouldve made vig to commit suicide if they killed town so the player would think twice before going trigger happy xDD I take the blame for the death of aa dono since it was my claim that you basically targeted a train. Although if it was me, Id always go for the last dude on the train xDD |
| Me too, pls! x) |
Gwendolly said: SightlessReality said: @Lord_Sithis Just consider this experience. When your in a situation with a unknown third party around & there are only 3 people left. Lynch the third party. To be honest, so long as you did what I did with my shop purchase(right at night start buy) you were basically un touchable. Even if Karote was scum if they attacked you they would just die instead. Same goes for Gwen here which is why I don't entirely agree with the end result. I already had a second window open to message shad immediately when the shop opens :P If I wouldnt have got the paralyze potion, I would have just killed Karote and buy the 50% accuracy potion, but pretty sure I would have gotten the paralyze potion..because Sithis was confused as hell and Karote wasnt there x) Next phase could have been fun I guess You were still screwed even if you did that either way. Since if you wasted all your money on that and went after Karote then you'd be dead the next night or the next or the next. Which would have meant town would win anyways since you left Lord alive. His ability is the perfect counter to your own so. Yeah. |
|
| Whats the scum club? Is it the secret club? Me wanna see too D: |
| <3 |
SightlessReality said: Gwendolly said: I already had a second window open to message shad immediately when the shop opens :P If I wouldnt have got the paralyze potion, I would have just killed Karote and buy the 50% accuracy potion, but pretty sure I would have gotten the paralyze potion..because Sithis was confused as hell and Karote wasnt there x) Next phase could have been fun I guess You were still screwed even if you did that either way. Since if you wasted all your money on that and went after Karote then you'd be dead the next night or the next or the next. Which would have meant town would win anyways since you left Lord alive. His ability is the perfect counter to your own so. Yeah. I can roleblock his role, I asked shad. |
| <3 |
Gwendolly said: SightlessReality said: You were still screwed even if you did that either way. Since if you wasted all your money on that and went after Karote then you'd be dead the next night or the next or the next. Which would have meant town would win anyways since you left Lord alive. His ability is the perfect counter to your own so. Yeah. I can roleblock his role, I asked shad. I'm not saying you couldn't I'm saying you used all that money to protect yourself for that night & leave Lord alive. If you have no money left you can't roleblock him. Which means defeat or impasse. All the while he could gather enough money to bring someone back. |
|
DenjaX said: SightlessReality said: i dont understand what you didnt agree on? Also Karote as scum would abstain from killing for him to waste the item and the game would drag even longer xDDLord_Sithis Just consider this experience. When your in a situation with a unknown third party around & there are only 3 people left. Lynch the third party. To be honest, so long as you did what I did with my shop purchase(right at night start buy) you were basically un touchable. Even if Karote was scum if they attacked you they would just die instead. Same goes for Gwen here which is why I don't entirely agree with the end result. Also, shouldve made vig to commit suicide if they killed town so the player would think twice before going trigger happy xDD I take the blame for the death of aa dono since it was my claim that you basically targeted a train. Although if it was me, Id always go for the last dude on the train xDD Shoot first, ask questions later. Doesn't matter to me. :) I'd still be trigger happy. |
|
SightlessReality said: I'm not saying you couldn't I'm saying you used all that money to protect yourself for that night & leave Lord alive. If you have no money left you can't roleblock him. Which means deat or impass. Which money? I had plenty...I only bought the potion that would investigate me as town..it cost 40gil and I earned 40 gil for the first quest...after that I didnt buy anything anymore...I did every quest too. |
| <3 |
Gwendolly said: Doesn't matter if you have alot left or not. As so as you run out or Lord is faster your screwed. One way or the other.SightlessReality said: I'm not saying you couldn't I'm saying you used all that money to protect yourself for that night & leave Lord alive. If you have no money left you can't roleblock him. Which means deat or impass. Which money? I had plenty...I only bought the potion that would investigate me as town..it cost 40gil and I earned 40 gil for the first quest...after that I didnt buy anything anymore...I did every quest too. |
|
Gwendolly said: join our discord gwennie :3Whats the scum club? Is it the secret club? Me wanna see too D: |
|
SightlessReality said: Gwendolly said: Doesn't matter if you have alot left or not. As so as you run out or Lord is faster your screwed. One way or the other.Which money? I had plenty...I only bought the potion that would investigate me as town..it cost 40gil and I earned 40 gil for the first quest...after that I didnt buy anything anymore...I did every quest too. Run out of what? Once I buy the potion, it was game over already. And the potion would be just for safety, maybe I didnt even need it. |
| <3 |
Gwendolly said: SightlessReality said: Doesn't matter if you have alot left or not. As so as you run out or Lord is faster your screwed. One way or the other. Run out of what? Once I buy the potion, it was game over already. And the potion would be just for safety, maybe I didnt even need it. Nope, I don't agree to that. |
|
Gwendolly said: SightlessReality said: Doesn't matter if you have alot left or not. As so as you run out or Lord is faster your screwed. One way or the other. Run out of what? Once I buy the potion, it was game over already. And the potion would be just for safety, maybe I didnt even need it. If I can say something. Gwen's kill would have been strongmanned anyways, making it impossible to manipulate. |
 |
shadroxx2810 said: Yes .... maybe if I lived a little longer ;-;1. Is the game enjoyable as a whole? 2. Opinions on the setup? You always make interesting set-ups ^^3. If there's something you dislike about the setup, what is it and why? Not sure ><4. Opinion on me as a host, what should i do to improve myself? [/center] Pretty good. (though sometimes I think perhaps too responsive - but Idk if this is good or bad, really) so good ^^Anyway, @SightlessReality why did you kill me? D: What on earth made you think I'm scum? |
 |
Soren said: Gwendolly said: join our discord gwennie :3Whats the scum club? Is it the secret club? Me wanna see too D: Invite me :D |
| <3 |
| Oh congrats @Gwendolly You played a good game ^^ |
|
aa-dono said: shadroxx2810 said: Yes .... maybe if I lived a little longer ;-;1. Is the game enjoyable as a whole? 2. Opinions on the setup? You always make interesting set-ups ^^3. If there's something you dislike about the setup, what is it and why? Not sure ><4. Opinion on me as a host, what should i do to improve myself? [/center] Pretty good. (though sometimes I think perhaps too responsive - but Idk if this is good or bad, really) so good ^^Anyway, @SightlessReality why did you kill me? D: What on earth made you think I'm scum? You were on day one train. Pretty much the only reason. If anything, my lack of not wanting to kill for revenge is what made me do it. Since if I went with that logic Claire would be dead instead of you. So, in a way me trying to not be biased ended up being the wrong choice. ^^; |
SightlessRealityOct 10, 2016 10:33 AM
|
Chione said: I disagree.Gwendolly said: Run out of what? Once I buy the potion, it was game over already. And the potion would be just for safety, maybe I didnt even need it. If I can say something. Gwen's kill would have been strongmanned anyways, making it impossible to manipulate. |
|
SightlessReality said: thats the way I like. I never held vig role before but id do the same lmao.DenjaX said: i dont understand what you didnt agree on? Also Karote as scum would abstain from killing for him to waste the item and the game would drag even longer xDD Also, shouldve made vig to commit suicide if they killed town so the player would think twice before going trigger happy xDD I take the blame for the death of aa dono since it was my claim that you basically targeted a train. Although if it was me, Id always go for the last dude on the train xDD Shoot first, ask questions later. Doesn't matter to me. :) I'd still be trigger happy. Why you revived grr? You shouldve revived me xDD |
| Removed roles As the original member was 24 not 22 |
 Thanks to vanitystar for making it |
DenjaX said: Cause of his unlimited Doctor Ability. He wasn't an X-ShotSightlessReality said: thats the way I like. I never held vig role before but id do the same lmao.Shoot first, ask questions later. Doesn't matter to me. :) I'd still be trigger happy. Why you revived grr? You shouldve revived me xDD |
|
Hah, I was thinking the whole time: There must be a 2nd third party member, there he goes! |
| <3 |
Gwendolly said: Hah, I was thinking the whole time: There must be a 2nd third party member, there he goes! The fun part is, his not from a final fantasy franchise, his from chrono trigger XDD |
Thanks to vanitystar for making it |
| The activity in the scum club was kinda disappointing. :\ Oh well. I do like that I brought fear into the hearts of scum on the third night though. :3 |
SightlessRealityOct 10, 2016 11:03 AM
|
SightlessReality said: ahh so you ddnt know about revived players gets vanillized.DenjaX said: Cause of his unlimited Doctor Ability. He wasn't an X-Shotthats the way I like. I never held vig role before but id do the same lmao. Why you revived grr? You shouldve revived me xDD |
DenjaX said: SightlessReality said: ahh so you ddnt know about revived players gets vanillized.Cause of his unlimited Doctor Ability. He wasn't an X-Shot Nope. |
|
| 1. Yeh, it was pretty fun. 2. Setup was fun 3. No real complaints here. 4. You seemed pretty responsive to things, overall a pretty good host. The game felt nice and balanced and the vote counts were nicely frequent. |
shadroxx2810 said: Indeed, Frog from Chrono Trigger. Got to love that game!Gwendolly said: Hah, I was thinking the whole time: There must be a 2nd third party member, there he goes! The fun part is, his not from a final fantasy franchise, his from chrono trigger XDD |
Lord_Sithis said: shadroxx2810 said: Indeed, Frog from Chrono Trigger. Got to love that game!The fun part is, his not from a final fantasy franchise, his from chrono trigger XDD Most defintely, I actually wanted to see what would the reactions be if he was inside this game, but that wasn't the case unfortunately. |
Thanks to vanitystar for making it |
| Congrats on winning Gwen ^^ I'll have to apologize to the town for my performance this game, I was too tunneled on searching out the last scum, I didn't think of the possibility of a 4-man scum team or else I would've been more suspicious of the survivor claim.. I can't believe I didn't see it this is probably the only time I can remember trusting a survivor claim because they are always lying in my experience >.> I also acted way too defeatist after Coro's case on me, I was feeling kind of mad and like I was being framed because of her roleblock on me and after I was wrong about Claire. I should have just aggressively defended myself from the start, after all no scum would NOT bus their buddy in that situation so I should've drawn more attention to that argument so that people would realize it. I am happy at least about catching on to Holo early. @Coromandel we make a great team, I'd love to play with you again sometime : ) Also @SightlessReality check out column DU of Chione's spreadsheet to see that I really did use the X potion >.> |
 |
Togs said: Congrats on winning Gwen ^^ I'll have to apologize to the town for my performance this game, I was too tunneled on searching out the last scum, I didn't think of the possibility of a 4-man scum team or else I would've been more suspicious of the survivor claim.. I can't believe I didn't see it this is probably the only time I can remember trusting a survivor claim because they are always lying in my experience >.> I also acted way too defeatist after Coro's case on me, I was feeling kind of mad and like I was being framed because of her roleblock on me and after I was wrong about Claire. I should have just aggressively defended myself from the start, after all no scum would NOT bus their buddy in that situation so I should've drawn more attention to that argument so that people would realize it. I am happy at least about catching on to Holo early. @Coromandel we make a great team, I'd love to play with you again sometime : ) Also @SightlessReality check out column DU of Chione's spreadsheet to see that I really did use the X potion >.> I really did use it too. |
|
SightlessReality said: Togs said: Congrats on winning Gwen ^^ I'll have to apologize to the town for my performance this game, I was too tunneled on searching out the last scum, I didn't think of the possibility of a 4-man scum team or else I would've been more suspicious of the survivor claim.. I can't believe I didn't see it this is probably the only time I can remember trusting a survivor claim because they are always lying in my experience >.> I also acted way too defeatist after Coro's case on me, I was feeling kind of mad and like I was being framed because of her roleblock on me and after I was wrong about Claire. I should have just aggressively defended myself from the start, after all no scum would NOT bus their buddy in that situation so I should've drawn more attention to that argument so that people would realize it. I am happy at least about catching on to Holo early. @Coromandel we make a great team, I'd love to play with you again sometime : ) Also @SightlessReality check out column DU of Chione's spreadsheet to see that I really did use the X potion >.> I really did use it too. Then why does the spreadsheet say I used it ? :0 |
|
SightlessReality said: Togs said: Congrats on winning Gwen ^^ I'll have to apologize to the town for my performance this game, I was too tunneled on searching out the last scum, I didn't think of the possibility of a 4-man scum team or else I would've been more suspicious of the survivor claim.. I can't believe I didn't see it this is probably the only time I can remember trusting a survivor claim because they are always lying in my experience >.> I also acted way too defeatist after Coro's case on me, I was feeling kind of mad and like I was being framed because of her roleblock on me and after I was wrong about Claire. I should have just aggressively defended myself from the start, after all no scum would NOT bus their buddy in that situation so I should've drawn more attention to that argument so that people would realize it. I am happy at least about catching on to Holo early. @Coromandel we make a great team, I'd love to play with you again sometime : ) Also @SightlessReality check out column DU of Chione's spreadsheet to see that I really did use the X potion >.> I really did use it too. Togs brougth it one night before you and kept it. He uses his on the same night phase as you use it. |
Thanks to vanitystar for making it |
I don't know, I asked after you told me to ask and I was told I used both. |
|
| @Coromandel I'm assuming what happened is you made a privet club to tally everything down for your posts and things of remarkable interest. And in one of those you accidentally quoted a post that had everyone alive at the times tag. Correct? The Thread you made was titled "FF Posts". |
SightlessRealityOct 10, 2016 12:24 PM
|
| Not sure why you'd throw..... But oh well |
SightlessReality said: @Coromandel I'm assuming what happened is you made a privet club to tally everything down for your posts and things of remarkable interest. And in one of those you accidentally quoted a post that had everyone alive at the times tag. Correct? The Thread you made was titled "FF Posts". You must have been notified from my "interesting posts" summary. I'm not sure whether it was in a club or a private blog post because I had several places where I "stored" my notes. I just summed up what each of you said and put it under quote-tags (but didn't quote anyone directly). I didn't know this would notify people too. And the strange thing is that we tried this several times afterwards (Shad and I) - and Shad wasn't notified. But lesson learnt, from now on I'm only going to post links to quotes and copy/paste the text. Togs said: Congrats on winning Gwen ^^ I'll have to apologize to the town for my performance this game, I was too tunneled on searching out the last scum, I didn't think of the possibility of a 4-man scum team or else I would've been more suspicious of the survivor claim.. I can't believe I didn't see it this is probably the only time I can remember trusting a survivor claim because they are always lying in my experience >.> I also acted way too defeatist after Coro's case on me, I was feeling kind of mad and like I was being framed because of her roleblock on me and after I was wrong about Claire. I should have just aggressively defended myself from the start, after all no scum would NOT bus their buddy in that situation so I should've drawn more attention to that argument so that people would realize it. I am happy at least about catching on to Holo early. @Coromandel we make a great team, I'd love to play with you again sometime : ) Also @SightlessReality check out column DU of Chione's spreadsheet to see that I really did use the X potion >.> Um, I'm really sorry. >.> I'd collected "evidence" during the night, then there was no nightkill after I roleblocked you + Sightless countering your claim about the potion made you look shady too. Yeah, looking forward to playing with you again! |
coromandelOct 10, 2016 12:51 PM
| 1. Is the game enjoyable as a whole? I like closed setups and the random factor in the game was limited so I really enjoyed it. 2. Opinions on the setup? Was qweeny able to use limit break + the other ability at the same night. If this is so I think it was a bit too much. probably 2 kills only would be fine (and maybe adding one more mafia). By making this ability strong this adds a bit disbalance: if the ability is used, town would have very low chance to win. But more importantly if the SK died early town would be way too OP. 3. If there's something you dislike about the setup, what is it and why? I still can't understand what was this all about. It came out of nowhere. 4. Opinion on me as a host, what should i do to improve myself? I think you can tag the dead players using @playersName so if they are too distracted to pay attention to things they can know in advance and not post after their death. |
 |
| I would love to see all the actions in this game. I think lupadim, slightest reality and claire played very well. Rinto and I learned the hard way we should back read before posting >.> . If I didn't die and rinto didn't replace claire I wouldn't ever let the town kill her thought she really got lucky because she had no way to know that my ability is "heal" and it just happened that hers is called the same. Coro togs and gweeny played very well too. Suzune did too but she had bad luck that her passive ability gives her away. I am disappointed by karote and lord sitis. Not only you lynched Togs, but also you didn't lynch gweny the last phase. And well lynching togs actually did good for town as mafia got baited and we could easily catch them but you didn't pointed at all that this is your goal. You just got lucky. I don't think I have played with lord sithis before, but I didn't expected this carrot : D . |
| |
Chione said: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1csP3ozpWlGSN-z-Mz6W_dx45jfa0mHsUQWk5BJAKtzQ/edit#gid=0 ^^^ if everyone's interested in the EXP distribution. It's very messy and you'll probably not know which is what but yeah ^^ You can also look at the distribution on the second page of the sheet. oh god! I am surprised by the amount of work behind the tiny random numbers. I like the gil/xp system but the effort seems a bit too much. |
| |
| Congratulations Gwen! I'd like some credit for your win because I voted for you the first day so that must've given you all of my luck ^^)/ I'm joking but this was quite neat to keep up with to be honest. I didn't expect mafia to go down like that :9 How come we can't see the third party's abilities though? I wanna know what they used~ Thanks to the host and co-host for the game and although I died literally the first day (due to time difference not poor play style) I applaud this <3 |
 |
| Good game everyone. Gwen you played really well. You know my complaints about it already. I have been pretty vocal about them. They were all centered around the poison from the fact that I had to activate it to the way that the user found out it was me from their pm. That really shot us in the foot. If we knew it was going to basically tell them it was me then we would have never used it. Otherwise, the game went well. |
 Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
More topics from this board
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8752 |
by Aswin_Ash
»»
Jan 23, 11:52 AM |
|
» Chat Thread ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Fo - Jul 10, 2014 |
3741 |
by Jackrito
»»
Jan 11, 3:55 PM |
|
» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Lambtron - May 15, 2018 |
1161 |
by Jackrito
»»
Jan 9, 8:12 AM |
|
» [GAME] (*￣･￣)ﾉ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2870 |
by Jackrito
»»
Jan 8, 11:22 AM |
|
» [GAME] (*￣･￣)ﾉ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated MEMBER Posts! v1 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SoulEaterQUEEN - Mar 26, 2016 |
1990 |
by Serafos
»»
Aug 17, 2024 9:42 PM |