New
Mar 30, 2018 8:12 AM
#1151
Wisp-O said: hes not online... he's at work lmao edit: probably just reading when he gets the chances that green writing saying 'online' says otherwise. He better get back to work then and stop the lurking |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 8:13 AM
#1152
NewG said: lol xDWisp-O said: hes not online... he's at work lmao edit: probably just reading when he gets the chances that green writing saying 'online' says otherwise. He better get back to work then and stop the lurking |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Mar 30, 2018 8:13 AM
#1153
Wisp-O said: but then again... If he is scum he wouldve never retracted the claim... fuck this dude is def town... this is what happens when I think... I just hurt myself xD If Shin is town; I also believe he would have more votes on him by now lol |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 8:16 AM
#1154
NewG said: logic doesnt work like that... with timezones, life, and everything... and naturally scum wouldnt make it that obvious by all voting on him at once, everyone else would be uninformed... There are so many variables that can explain many concepts in mafia, and you saying that he is scum, because he hasnt garnered X amount of votes, is irrelevantWisp-O said: but then again... If he is scum he wouldve never retracted the claim... fuck this dude is def town... this is what happens when I think... I just hurt myself xD If Shin is town; I also believe he would have more votes on him by now lol |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Mar 30, 2018 8:18 AM
#1155
Wisp-O said: NewG said: logic doesnt work like that... with timezones, life, and everything... and naturally scum wouldnt make it that obvious by all voting on him at once, everyone else would be uninformed... There are so many variables that can explain many concepts in mafia, and you saying that he is scum, because he hasnt garnered X amount of votes, is irrelevantWisp-O said: but then again... If he is scum he wouldve never retracted the claim... fuck this dude is def town... this is what happens when I think... I just hurt myself xD If Shin is town; I also believe he would have more votes on him by now lol I know, but the fact that most of the people here aren't even questioning him after what he did. And we've got it b/w on paper!!! Why not pressure him? |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 8:21 AM
#1156
NewG said: are you asking me why not? or are you saying that as a general question, like why not? and I cant tell you why more people arent questioning him? I do need him to give a clear and concise reason for why he did what he did tho. and not everything is black and white... dont use that shit in mafia smhWisp-O said: NewG said: Wisp-O said: but then again... If he is scum he wouldve never retracted the claim... fuck this dude is def town... this is what happens when I think... I just hurt myself xD If Shin is town; I also believe he would have more votes on him by now lol I know, but the fact that most of the people here aren't even questioning him after what he did. And we've got it b/w on paper!!! Why not pressure him? |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Mar 30, 2018 8:24 AM
#1157
Wisp-O said: NewG said: are you asking me why not? or are you saying that as a general question, like why not? and I cant tell you why more people arent questioning him? I do need him to give a clear and concise reason for why he did what he did tho. and not everything is black and white... dont use that shit in mafia smhWisp-O said: NewG said: logic doesnt work like that... with timezones, life, and everything... and naturally scum wouldnt make it that obvious by all voting on him at once, everyone else would be uninformed... There are so many variables that can explain many concepts in mafia, and you saying that he is scum, because he hasnt garnered X amount of votes, is irrelevantWisp-O said: but then again... If he is scum he wouldve never retracted the claim... fuck this dude is def town... this is what happens when I think... I just hurt myself xD If Shin is town; I also believe he would have more votes on him by now lol I know, but the fact that most of the people here aren't even questioning him after what he did. And we've got it b/w on paper!!! Why not pressure him? Look at the set-up look at what Shinichi said. Now compare them! He started with the whole mechanical talk and now I am gonna use this against him, he burried his own grave! If you're curious then pressure and vote for him, logic ain't gonna run away. |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 8:26 AM
#1158
NewG said: no my vote will stay on Logic, I asked Shin my questions, I just need his answers, adding one more vote wont change much, if he refuses to answer my questions, then I will move over to his train.Wisp-O said: NewG said: Wisp-O said: NewG said: logic doesnt work like that... with timezones, life, and everything... and naturally scum wouldnt make it that obvious by all voting on him at once, everyone else would be uninformed... There are so many variables that can explain many concepts in mafia, and you saying that he is scum, because he hasnt garnered X amount of votes, is irrelevantWisp-O said: but then again... If he is scum he wouldve never retracted the claim... fuck this dude is def town... this is what happens when I think... I just hurt myself xD If Shin is town; I also believe he would have more votes on him by now lol I know, but the fact that most of the people here aren't even questioning him after what he did. And we've got it b/w on paper!!! Why not pressure him? Look at the set-up look at what Shinichi said. Now compare them! He started with the whole mechanical talk and now I am gonna use this against him, he burried his own grave! If you're curious then pressure and vote for him, logic ain't gonna run away. |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Mar 30, 2018 8:32 AM
#1159
If we focus on one end of the spectrum, we our bound to fail in this game... Virtue comes in moderation... if we focus to much on mechanical reasons to scum/town read someone, then we will fail in our attempt to mod game this setup, and if we focus to much on how each person's individuality then we will fail because we cant honestly began to fathom on how one thinks, shin is an enigma either way... |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Mar 30, 2018 8:34 AM
#1160
RE said: Shinichi-Kun said: That doesn't answer my question. What did you hope to accomplish with that? Had you been counterclaimed, you would be almost guaranteed a lynch. I see no benefit in town lying about their claim.RE said: Phraze said: Why would town lie about their role? Ever?Wisp-O said: nah the way he gone about it was townWell w/e we got time tmr... @shinichi-kun don't expect to believe anything u say this game now i am town and i just did lol Wish RE was here. Not gonna wine about why she was killed. But I believe she would have figured this out ;-; |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 8:36 AM
#1161
NewG said: re is always too townie not to kill :'(RE said: Shinichi-Kun said: RE said: Phraze said: Why would town lie about their role? Ever?Wisp-O said: nah the way he gone about it was townWell w/e we got time tmr... @shinichi-kun don't expect to believe anything u say this game now i am town and i just did lol Wish RE was here. Not gonna wine about why she was killed. But I believe she would have figured this out ;-; |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Mar 30, 2018 8:38 AM
#1162
Wisp-O said: If we focus on one end of the spectrum, we our bound to fail in this game... Virtue comes in moderation... if we focus to much on mechanical reasons to scum/town read someone, then we will fail in our attempt to mod game this setup, and if we focus to much on how each person's individuality then we will fail because we cant honestly began to fathom on how one thinks, shin is an enigma either way... Get rid of the enigma then and all your problems will be solved. |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 8:39 AM
#1163
NewG said: lol... also tainted seems to always get a clear town read around the table... wonder why he wasnt killed...Wisp-O said: If we focus on one end of the spectrum, we our bound to fail in this game... Virtue comes in moderation... if we focus to much on mechanical reasons to scum/town read someone, then we will fail in our attempt to mod game this setup, and if we focus to much on how each person's individuality then we will fail because we cant honestly began to fathom on how one thinks, shin is an enigma either way... Get rid of the enigma then and all your problems will be solved. |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Mar 30, 2018 8:41 AM
#1164
Wisp-O said: NewG said: re is always too townie not to kill :'(RE said: Shinichi-Kun said: That doesn't answer my question. What did you hope to accomplish with that? Had you been counterclaimed, you would be almost guaranteed a lynch. I see no benefit in town lying about their claim.RE said: Phraze said: Why would town lie about their role? Ever?Wisp-O said: nah the way he gone about it was townWell w/e we got time tmr... @shinichi-kun don't expect to believe anything u say this game now i am town and i just did lol Wish RE was here. Not gonna wine about why she was killed. But I believe she would have figured this out ;-; Wisp-O said: NewG said: lol... also tainted seems to always get a clear town read around the table... wonder why he wasnt killed...Wisp-O said: If we focus on one end of the spectrum, we our bound to fail in this game... Virtue comes in moderation... if we focus to much on mechanical reasons to scum/town read someone, then we will fail in our attempt to mod game this setup, and if we focus to much on how each person's individuality then we will fail because we cant honestly began to fathom on how one thinks, shin is an enigma either way... Get rid of the enigma then and all your problems will be solved. Thought Re was in cahoots with Shin at first <.< Tainted can be read as both imo |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 8:43 AM
#1165
logic340 said: claims and what we know Curious Investigators (1 in play) RE Femmes Fatales (1 in play) Century - Neighbor The Jealous Mobster (1 in play) Townspeople (4 in play) Wisp Phraze NewG Those Who Hide (1 in play) roz1roz Killers (2 in game) Intrigue (2 in game) Logic - Pathetic Fallacy Wild Card (1 in game) Might want to add a Jailor, because there is definitely one in play. |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 8:45 AM
#1166
Wisp-O said: There goes our investigator... So I think Shin is lock town, anyone else? Karote spent all day on yurkin, then snipes to save her... seems like W/W to me Logic is still scum hands down, gwen much less Mafia Jailkeeper is def in this game, ill explain later if I need to EXPLAIN! edit: and how was I less scum before my claim? |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 8:49 AM
#1167
Shinichi-Kun said: logic340 said: @Shinichi-kun can you explain your thought process in tying the vote 5 minutes before phase change the quick changing it back 1 minute beforei phase change? What there to explain? Did you not read the EOD or are u just playing the part of an idiot XD? I did not want a tie so i voted yurkin, karote then changed his vote roz so therefore i changed my vote back to roz to stop a tie. It seems pretty self explanatory. There wouldnt have been a tie btw, because Karote removed his vote from yurkin. |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 8:49 AM
#1168
logic340 ISO. Day 1 logic340 said: @Shinichi-kun I want your Syo forum set hand it over. Also why do you think Shinichi is role fishing so heavy to start this game? logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: yes and yes. I asked before I want it badly.logic340 said: @Shinichi-kun I want your Syo forum set hand it over. Also why do you think Shinichi is role fishing so heavy to start this game? are u asking me that question lol? Genicide jack one? logic340 said: vote: no lynch logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: wouldn't this cause harm to potential town pr's?Pathetic Fallacy: Town Named Vanilla I also think if this role exists someone should claim it cause it harms no one for thiis role to be claimed. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: bolded sounds horrible tho. If a fifth vt exists how does coming forward help town? Is that player like IC in it eyes after that? To me the con out weighs the pro.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: wouldn't this cause harm to potential town pr's?Pathetic Fallacy: Town Named Vanilla I also think if this role exists someone should claim it cause it harms no one for thiis role to be claimed. Outside of narrowing down potential pr, when 4 vanilla townies exist i doubt it. Plus the only other PR in that section is a backup. logic340 said: Wisp-O said: explain your reasoning for me if you wouldn't mind?Actually I take that back, I think both town and mafia are equally harmed by vanilla claims. So I wouldnt mind some vanilla claims logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: I agree town shouldn't lie, but that's not what we're discussing. We're talking about proper time to claim Pathetic Fallacy.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: bolded sounds horrible tho. If a fifth vt exists how does coming forward help town? Is that player like IC in it eyes after that? To me the con out weighs the pro.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: wouldn't this cause harm to potential town pr's?Pathetic Fallacy: Town Named Vanilla I also think if this role exists someone should claim it cause it harms no one for thiis role to be claimed. Outside of narrowing down potential pr, when 4 vanilla townies exist i doubt it. Plus the only other PR in that section is a backup. No not at all, but i dont think town should be lieing about being a vt makes literally no sense for someone thats town to lie about that, it actually harms town. logic340 said: Majority lynch lock is in play this game people logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: whenever they feel like it, before they would get lynched, massclaim time.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: I agree town shouldn't lie, but that's not what we're discussing. We're talking about proper time to claim Pathetic Fallacy.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: bolded sounds horrible tho. If a fifth vt exists how does coming forward help town? Is that player like IC in it eyes after that? To me the con out weighs the pro.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: wouldn't this cause harm to potential town pr's?Pathetic Fallacy: Town Named Vanilla I also think if this role exists someone should claim it cause it harms no one for thiis role to be claimed. Outside of narrowing down potential pr, when 4 vanilla townies exist i doubt it. Plus the only other PR in that section is a backup. No not at all, but i dont think town should be lieing about being a vt makes literally no sense for someone thats town to lie about that, it actually harms town. WHich is when? I'll ask you again are they like IC (or maybe mayor) to you if they claim now? If not I'm not really seeing the benefit for town more for scim imo. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: I'd prefer a possible dichotomy. To each his own...Century_Orion said: Just found out that this is open setup semi open to be exact RE said: vote: Shinichi thiis just random? cause now i am at 3 votes logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: whenever they feel like it, before they would get lynched, massclaim time.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: I agree town shouldn't lie, but that's not what we're discussing. We're talking about proper time to claim Pathetic Fallacy.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: bolded sounds horrible tho. If a fifth vt exists how does coming forward help town? Is that player like IC in it eyes after that? To me the con out weighs the pro.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: wouldn't this cause harm to potential town pr's?Pathetic Fallacy: Town Named Vanilla I also think if this role exists someone should claim it cause it harms no one for thiis role to be claimed. Outside of narrowing down potential pr, when 4 vanilla townies exist i doubt it. Plus the only other PR in that section is a backup. No not at all, but i dont think town should be lieing about being a vt makes literally no sense for someone thats town to lie about that, it actually harms town. WHich is when? I'll ask you again are the like IC (or maybe mayor) to you if they claim now? If not I'm not really seeing the benefit for town more for scim imo. Of course now but i rather a flavored vanilla be out, before something evil tries to use it against us -.- logic340 said: shinichi said: you kind of asked for it with that self vote. thiis just random? cause now i am at 3 votes logic340 said: 13 players in this game I'm willing to bet there are at least 3 scum. I dont think it would be balanced otherwise. because I like to bring awareness to this voting option for town. My reasoning mafia don't want a longer game it's harder on them. Will put it somewhere better later, for now this is fine. logic340 said: I'm against massclaimimg as I am a Behavioral player who isn't that good at mechanics. While massclaiming would provide an opportunity to get better at mechanics I'll decline at this time. logic340 said: Wisp-O said: there was something to bet tho....here on MS We're not in the business of putting out unbalanced games. There's still mystery regardless. You're not feeling townie here wisplogic340 said: 13 players in this game I'm willing to bet there are at least 3 scum. I dont think it would be balanced otherwise. because I like to bring awareness to this voting option for town. My reasoning mafia don't want a longer game it's harder on them. Will put it somewhere better later, for now this is fine. unvote: Vote: wisp-o logic340 said: RE said: how is neighborizer useless as town? Suzune used it masterfully in Alcatraz mafia. I think you're just scared of it because I got you with it in Easter Egg Mafia last year. I'll check her catch up post but this defense of shin is BAD.Wowa vote: NewG Your catch up feels fake, and while Shinichi has spent most of his time discussing roles, his strategy isn't wrong. I think neighborizer should claim. Their role is next to useless as town and dangerous as scum. logic340 said: RE said: You Even voted him and said it wasn't rvsvote: Shinichi RE said: Not random, calling out the miller felt like busy work and unnecessary. But we'll see. Now you defend him? Idk which is worse his play or you protecting him now? logic340 said: Tainted said: you misunderstand me. She is scared of scum neighbor not town neighbor. She feels town neighbor is useless. Idk what to make of her yet.logic340 said: RE said: how is neighborizer useless as town? Suzune used it masterfully in Alcatraz mafia. I think you're just scared of it because I got you with it in Easter Egg Mafia last year. I'll check her catch up post but this defense of shin is BAD.Wowa vote: NewG Your catch up feels fake, and while Shinichi has spent most of his time discussing roles, his strategy isn't wrong. I think neighborizer should claim. Their role is next to useless as town and dangerous as scum. Why else would she be scared of a town neighborizer. logic340 said: so your leaning scum here fur to this "tell"? logic340 said: Tainted said: things that aren't in scum favor to discuss. Why help mafia right off the bat?logic340 said: RE said: You Even voted him and said it wasn't rvsvote: Shinichi RE said: Not random, calling out the miller felt like busy work and unnecessary. But we'll see. Now you defend him? Idk which is worse his play or you protecting him now? logic340 said: roz1roz said: I was thinking about it and this seems more reasonable but also helps mafia identify town power roles. Still seems to help scum more than town imo. Can you enlighten me? Am I missing something?I still say that scum is worried of unknown and that massclaim can hurt them greatly, so they would deny this option. I don't say about role massclaim, but a group massclaim (as of in wich group are you). That alone should give a lot of info. logic340 said: Tainted said: I disagree mechanics talk as scum allows you to look like your doing something while information gathering or confusing town. Mechanics should be discussed when necessary I think it's unnecessary here. Even if shin is town he's making things easy for mafia. Easier for them to pick at him and easier for them to get involved in conversation.NewG said: Tainted said: logic340 said: idk why people find shin's play bad like I understand if he did it on d2 or later but he talked about it when the game just started where barely no one even posted yet like what else is there to talk about?RE said: You Even voted him and said it wasn't rvsvote: Shinichi RE said: Not random, calling out the miller felt like busy work and unnecessary. But we'll see. Now you defend him? Idk which is worse his play or you protecting him now? You said it yourself. Scum like to hide behind mechanical talk. And when's the better time if not D1? logic340 said: Tainted said: intention and outcome aren't always the same. See my last post #203logic340 said: Tainted said: things that aren't in scum favor to discuss. Why help mafia right off the bat?logic340 said: idk why people find shin's play bad like I understand if he did it on d2 or later but he talked about it when the game just started where barely no one even posted yet like what else is there to talk about?RE said: You Even voted him and said it wasn't rvsvote: Shinichi RE said: Not random, calling out the miller felt like busy work and unnecessary. But we'll see. Now you defend him? Idk which is worse his play or you protecting him now? logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: All the claiming you want would male this hard as invest could die N1.Wisp-O said: Ok lets start off with what is confirmed: 1. There are 4 Vanilla in play 2. The Jealous Mobster (1 in play) (Mafia Goon) 3. Those Who Hide (1 in play) (both roles in this group with show up as mafia aligned) Less Confirmed: I believe this game is semi flip and you only see the flavor group of the person that dies and gets lynched 3 will be harder to catch, hopefully if a cop exists they find the jealous mobster as soonas possible. roz1roz said: so you'd have them put themselves in a position. To get mislynched by lying a out their role? Not seeing how this helps town any?logic340 said: roz1roz said: I was thinking about it and this seems more reasonable but also helps mafia identify town power roles. Still seems to help scum more than town imo. Can you enlighten me? Am I missing something?I still say that scum is worried of unknown and that massclaim can hurt them greatly, so they would deny this option. I don't say about role massclaim, but a group massclaim (as of in wich group are you). That alone should give a lot of info. Curious investigator should claim cit during the massclaim. There is many routes to make it a safe massclaim. logic340 said: Tainted said: ask all you want, i have little to nothing at the moment and was doing a reread for that reason. In the mean time you can put yours out, since you expect people to have reads right now.Anyway this mechanic talk is turning to Shin talk.. @logic340 can I ask for your reads? logic340 said: Tainted said: Mindmelds are a good way to get yourself pocketed watch yourself. ScarletCelestial said: Well, I think Gwen has been doing as much mechanical talk as Shin-chan, so I don't know why this is being seen as an indicator. Shin-chan trying to get the Miller to claim is pretty average, though I wouldn't know why they wouldn't come forward themselves. (Of course, I'm using the assumption that Shin-chan had earlier.) Wisp defending his brother is non-alignment indicative really, it probably just means they're the same alignment as I think Wisp tends to have good reads on his brother (or only he is scum trying to trick Shin-chan knowing he is his greatest issue). His actions earlier make me feel kinda weird about him, in a bad way. Shin-chan's massclaim idea, though bad, I feel could come from either alignment. From Town it means it was to get the thread started, from scum to get people to claim early on. The way in which he went about it is what I feel better about. (See my next post.) Those are my thoughts on the brothers (And slightly on Gwen) thus far. logic340 said: Wisp-O said: your grasping at straws bro. Try harder.logic340 said: Tainted said: Mindmelds are a good way to get yourself pocketed watch yourself. ScarletCelestial said: mindmeld +1Well, I think Gwen has been doing as much mechanical talk as Shin-chan, so I don't know why this is being seen as an indicator. Shin-chan trying to get the Miller to claim is pretty average, though I wouldn't know why they wouldn't come forward themselves. (Of course, I'm using the assumption that Shin-chan had earlier.) Wisp defending his brother is non-alignment indicative really, it probably just means they're the same alignment as I think Wisp tends to have good reads on his brother (or only he is scum trying to trick Shin-chan knowing he is his greatest issue). His actions earlier make me feel kinda weird about him, in a bad way. Shin-chan's massclaim idea, though bad, I feel could come from either alignment. From Town it means it was to get the thread started, from scum to get people to claim early on. The way in which he went about it is what I feel better about. (See my next post.) Those are my thoughts on the brothers (And slightly on Gwen) thus far. like this All the claiming you want would male this hard as invest could die N1. I hate this post, sounds more like scared scum, then concerned townie logic340 said: Wisp-O said: What hanged your thought here? Just a change without showing the process?Actually I take that back, I think both town and mafia are equally harmed by vanilla claims. So I wouldnt mind some vanilla claims Phraze said: How are you so sure we're town (I assume my fellow townies refers to me and tainted here)?Tainted said: logic340 said: agree with logic here.Shinichi-Kun said: I'd prefer a possible dichotomy. To each his own...Century_Orion said: Just found out that this is open setup semi open to be exact RE said: vote: Shinichi thiis just random? cause now i am at 3 votes logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: whenever they feel like it, before they would get lynched, massclaim time.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: I agree town shouldn't lie, but that's not what we're discussing. We're talking about proper time to claim Pathetic Fallacy.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: bolded sounds horrible tho. If a fifth vt exists how does coming forward help town? Is that player like IC in it eyes after that? To me the con out weighs the pro.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: wouldn't this cause harm to potential town pr's?Pathetic Fallacy: Town Named Vanilla I also think if this role exists someone should claim it cause it harms no one for thiis role to be claimed. Outside of narrowing down potential pr, when 4 vanilla townies exist i doubt it. Plus the only other PR in that section is a backup. No not at all, but i dont think town should be lieing about being a vt makes literally no sense for someone thats town to lie about that, it actually harms town. WHich is when? I'll ask you again are the like IC (or maybe mayor) to you if they claim now? If not I'm not really seeing the benefit for town more for scim imo. Of course now but i rather a flavored vanilla be out, before something evil tries to use it against us -.- Let's just stop talking about claiming right now. It's an easy talk for scum to just jump in. yurkin said: elaborate maybe?#31 logic340 said: @Shinichi-kun I want your Syo forum set hand it over. Also why do you think Shinichi is role fishing so heavy to start this game? for some reason logic asking "why" here is sus. logic340 said: ScarletCelestial said: I was actually warming tainted...smh.Wisp-O said: ScarletCelestial said: how was the post about u? when logic quoted tainted...Wisp-O said: logic340 said: I dont think we need to worry about tainted getting pocketed... worry about ur lacking posts...Tainted said: Mindmelds are a good way to get yourself pocketed watch yourself. ScarletCelestial said: mindmeld +1Well, I think Gwen has been doing as much mechanical talk as Shin-chan, so I don't know why this is being seen as an indicator. Shin-chan trying to get the Miller to claim is pretty average, though I wouldn't know why they wouldn't come forward themselves. (Of course, I'm using the assumption that Shin-chan had earlier.) Wisp defending his brother is non-alignment indicative really, it probably just means they're the same alignment as I think Wisp tends to have good reads on his brother (or only he is scum trying to trick Shin-chan knowing he is his greatest issue). His actions earlier make me feel kinda weird about him, in a bad way. Shin-chan's massclaim idea, though bad, I feel could come from either alignment. From Town it means it was to get the thread started, from scum to get people to claim early on. The way in which he went about it is what I feel better about. (See my next post.) Those are my thoughts on the brothers (And slightly on Gwen) thus far. like this All the claiming you want would male this hard as invest could die N1. I hate this post, sounds more like scared scum, then concerned townie Wisp, that was directed to me. @NewG sure lol It was directed at me because logic thought I'd get pickpocketed by Tainted's "mindmeld+1". logic340 said: Tainted said: no read on me :cries:logic340 said: Tainted said: ask all you want, i have little to nothing at the moment and was doing a reread for that reason. In the mean time you can put yours out, since you expect people to have reads right now.Anyway this mechanic talk is turning to Shin talk.. @logic340 can I ask for your reads? Scar probably town Re slight town Wisp could be scum Gwen could also be scum kinda agree with Phraze there. Don't really have any strong reads but that's where I'm at logic340 said: @RE logic is anti-bus as mafia if I'm mafia here whisper is town. I'm down with Wisper scum for now tho. logic340 said: ScarletCelestial said: all I was saying is Mindmelds can lead to easy pocketing. Nothing to do with the work you put in. logic340 said: ScarletCelestial said: I was actually warming tainted...smh.Wisp-O said: ScarletCelestial said: how was the post about u? when logic quoted tainted...Wisp-O said: logic340 said: I dont think we need to worry about tainted getting pocketed... worry about ur lacking posts...Tainted said: Mindmelds are a good way to get yourself pocketed watch yourself. ScarletCelestial said: mindmeld +1Well, I think Gwen has been doing as much mechanical talk as Shin-chan, so I don't know why this is being seen as an indicator. Shin-chan trying to get the Miller to claim is pretty average, though I wouldn't know why they wouldn't come forward themselves. (Of course, I'm using the assumption that Shin-chan had earlier.) Wisp defending his brother is non-alignment indicative really, it probably just means they're the same alignment as I think Wisp tends to have good reads on his brother (or only he is scum trying to trick Shin-chan knowing he is his greatest issue). His actions earlier make me feel kinda weird about him, in a bad way. Shin-chan's massclaim idea, though bad, I feel could come from either alignment. From Town it means it was to get the thread started, from scum to get people to claim early on. The way in which he went about it is what I feel better about. (See my next post.) Those are my thoughts on the brothers (And slightly on Gwen) thus far. like this All the claiming you want would male this hard as invest could die N1. I hate this post, sounds more like scared scum, then concerned townie Wisp, that was directed to me. @NewG sure lol It was directed at me because logic thought I'd get pickpocketed by Tainted's "mindmeld+1". Really? Because I was the one who wrote those thoughts down. Tainted just went and said they had a mindmeld. I was the one who did the work, so I thought you were directing it to me... logic340 said: RE said: that's because I begged him not to bus Abu and he did. Ending in abu's lynch d1 and a downward spiral got the mafia team. You Do remember we (mafia) lost that game right? Bussing=bad for mafia (most times). I will bus if forced to but I'm anti-bus. So no I wouldn't be bussing this esrly.logic340 said: @RE logic is anti-bus as mafia if I'm mafia here whisper is town. I'm down with Wisper scum for now tho. White wine. logic340 said: ScarletCelestial said: I've been way more active than phraze tho? It'll work itself out I'm sure. logic340 said: Tainted said: no read on me :cries:logic340 said: Shin townTainted said: ask all you want, i have little to nothing at the moment and was doing a reread for that reason. In the mean time you can put yours out, since you expect people to have reads right now.Anyway this mechanic talk is turning to Shin talk.. @logic340 can I ask for your reads? Scar probably town Re slight town Wisp could be scum Gwen could also be scum kinda agree with Phraze there. Don't really have any strong reads but that's where I'm at Didn't give Phraze a read either... How do yoo feel about what's read list? Feels unoriginal to me like he's just recycling the sentiment of others in his read list. logic340 said: ScarletCelestial said: agreed.logic340 said: ScarletCelestial said: all I was saying is Mindmelds can lead to easy pocketing. Nothing to do with the work you put in. logic340 said: ScarletCelestial said: I was actually warming tainted...smh.Wisp-O said: ScarletCelestial said: how was the post about u? when logic quoted tainted...Wisp-O said: logic340 said: I dont think we need to worry about tainted getting pocketed... worry about ur lacking posts...Tainted said: Mindmelds are a good way to get yourself pocketed watch yourself. ScarletCelestial said: mindmeld +1Well, I think Gwen has been doing as much mechanical talk as Shin-chan, so I don't know why this is being seen as an indicator. Shin-chan trying to get the Miller to claim is pretty average, though I wouldn't know why they wouldn't come forward themselves. (Of course, I'm using the assumption that Shin-chan had earlier.) Wisp defending his brother is non-alignment indicative really, it probably just means they're the same alignment as I think Wisp tends to have good reads on his brother (or only he is scum trying to trick Shin-chan knowing he is his greatest issue). His actions earlier make me feel kinda weird about him, in a bad way. Shin-chan's massclaim idea, though bad, I feel could come from either alignment. From Town it means it was to get the thread started, from scum to get people to claim early on. The way in which he went about it is what I feel better about. (See my next post.) Those are my thoughts on the brothers (And slightly on Gwen) thus far. like this All the claiming you want would male this hard as invest could die N1. I hate this post, sounds more like scared scum, then concerned townie Wisp, that was directed to me. @NewG sure lol It was directed at me because logic thought I'd get pickpocketed by Tainted's "mindmeld+1". Really? Because I was the one who wrote those thoughts down. Tainted just went and said they had a mindmeld. I was the one who did the work, so I thought you were directing it to me... I think this is just a weird conversation based on misunderstandings. Moving on to more pertinent subjects. I find phraze hard to read have you had any luck reading her in previous games? logic340 said: RE said: roz thinking doesn't surprise me, not looking at how it negatively affects town does. I'd put him to the scummies side of neutral but haven't seen enough from him yet.What are people's thoughts on roz's mass claim idea? Logic pointed this out already, but roz suggested Curious Investigators to claim Citizen to avoid putting target on their back, which would do more harm than good since there's a set number of 4 citizens. Which is also a pretty obvious conclusion, so I find it pretty suspicious roz didn't think that through. logic340 said: Wisp-O said: could you highlight some of these "questionable posts"? Maybe that will help move me one way or the other?Logic - usual logic, with his vote to no lynch, still think its stupid, and he has some questionable posts... nothing major to place him yet logic340 said: Work calls I'll be back shortly logic340 said: @RE there are no thoughts currently as I haven't reread yet? So yes it was answered on my response to tainted who asked for my reads. You asking for a specific read didn't change that... logic340 said: Wisp-O said: holding on to.old shit? It's been so long since I played a forum mafia game. Since Oct when anyone last saw my town game even.@logic340 To be short and sweet, your posts to be come off as more, your train of thought is wrong, or mine is right. I don't believe that to be the correct way to look at things. I mean posts can be wrong, but they are more a long the line of good or bad, rather then wrong or right. Maybe it's just me, I have a sorta of confrontational bias when it comes to how you attack posts and how you respond to people. edit: so what are you comparing to? logic340 said: Wisp-O said: knocking the rust off, don't expect too much from me.And ur train of thought on how things should be this game, is too much wine, then usual from you logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: if it was that easy to catch them we would but you know from experience frivolous talk from town helps mafia. You're not a newb i won't accept this from youTainted said: logic340 said: agree with logic here.Shinichi-Kun said: I'd prefer a possible dichotomy. To each his own...Century_Orion said: Just found out that this is open setup semi open to be exact RE said: vote: Shinichi thiis just random? cause now i am at 3 votes logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: whenever they feel like it, before they would get lynched, massclaim time.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: I agree town shouldn't lie, but that's not what we're discussing. We're talking about proper time to claim Pathetic Fallacy.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: bolded sounds horrible tho. If a fifth vt exists how does coming forward help town? Is that player like IC in it eyes after that? To me the con out weighs the pro.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: wouldn't this cause harm to potential town pr's?Pathetic Fallacy: Town Named Vanilla I also think if this role exists someone should claim it cause it harms no one for thiis role to be claimed. Outside of narrowing down potential pr, when 4 vanilla townies exist i doubt it. Plus the only other PR in that section is a backup. No not at all, but i dont think town should be lieing about being a vt makes literally no sense for someone thats town to lie about that, it actually harms town. WHich is when? I'll ask you again are the like IC (or maybe mayor) to you if they claim now? If not I'm not really seeing the benefit for town more for scim imo. Of course now but i rather a flavored vanilla be out, before something evil tries to use it against us -.- Let's just stop talking about claiming right now. It's an easy talk for scum to just jump in. logic340 said: Tainted said: you shared a thought not really the process tho?NewG said: Tainted said: Shinichi-Kun said: meh I feel like shin is townI am more worred about the deceitful crook now because if he gets investigated he can just claim that he was given the innocent role :/, what a trouble some role. You feel? Or you know? Why make that feeling public? logic340 said: NewG said: I used knowledge of how MS runs games actually. No one wants to play a game that unbalanced (especially mafia).logic340 said: 13 players in this game I'm willing to bet there are at least 3 scum. I dont think it would be balanced otherwise. Looool, so much for people not reading the set-up. Does that make them town or scum? xD Logic read the above. edit: unless you went one step ahead and did the maths. logic340 said: NewG said: i feel like this is a townie post from gwen. If she's scum here then wisp is making it easy for scum to look town. Wisp-O said: NewG said: on what though? Lol pretty broad question. Gotta work on some stuff, be back laterWisp-O said: So if this game is psuedo randomized then probably a minimum of 3 scum Thoughts so far? On everything? You aren't a bystander dude. You haven't really tackled any issue here so far. There is lots to catch on. Thoughts on a massclaim coming from roz, thoughts on logic being against it, thoughts on Tainteds behaviour, thoughts on mine, thoughts on the votes etc? logic340 said: Wisp-O said: point am out instead then. Show the inconsistencies you're seeing then? Should be easy for a pro like you no?logic340 said: Wisp-O said: knocking the rust off, don't expect too much from me.And ur train of thought on how things should be this game, is too much wine, then usual from you logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: Why should any of our roles be hidden then? You sound like an as (donkey) I can't even call it scummy anymore maybe just misunderstood. Here is a thought lead by example and claim your role fool.NewG said: I agree with yurkin here. Shinichi is just saying obvious stuff in order to just say stuff. #21 why would a neighbourizer even claim with that high chance in others eyes? Like why mention it? Why put them out like this, if you're not scum? @Shinichi-kun #24 playing the worried in public #22 it harms town (like I already said) Shin is on my suspect list but I want answers first. Toodlez~ edit: added links, added a question why should a role that has a 50\50 chance to be scum not out themselves unless they're scum. #101-why are u reading into the thread and interactions assuming I am scum that's basis for a biased mind set. NewG said: NewG said: Shinichi-Kun said: I am gonna start off by saying this now, if a miller doesn claim in the next 24 hours i am gonna assume that slot is taking by the mafia goon, atleast until the wild cards role is known. Not sure if I got the hang of the wild card. Does that mean there are two roles of the same out there? I think I get it now and it just messes everything more up xD Still don't think people should claim voluntarily. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: bias clouding your judgement early? Seeting yourself up to scum read whoever claims naighbor.NewG said: RE said: NewG said: That's a very bold statement. It isn't necessary and you can play the game normally, but I think it can help because probability. You'd also do it as uninformed town. The role can just as easily be scum's.RE said: NewG said: Read my reply ^^Read my edit. In that case you're just scaring the neighbourizer away. So, again why point it out, if you yourself are not scum? Because why miss out on a 50/50 percent chance on knowing who is scum, without endangering any of the more useful roles? But WHY call out neighbourizer immediately? Is it necessary? You would only do that as informed scum. Well, if both you and Shin are town then you screwed up already by mentioning it lol longer neighborizer waits to claim the more they're screwing themselves, cause its gonna get to the point where i will not town read them. Noted logic340 said: Does shinichi always fear monger like this? Devil's advocate I remember not straight out fear mongering... logic340 said: For those who asked how I feel about gwen. I don't get the scum vibes I did the last time I nailed her as scum so town lean for now. I'm not seeing as much mechanics talk from gwen as Phraze alluded to. @phraze care to give examples to substantiate your claim? Mudslinging and slander isn't becoming of you dear. edit: typo logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: and if they are town then alln you did was give mafia one less nk target. Why kill outed neighbor when they can try to kill invest? I'm done with this mechanics talk with you it's a waste of time.Phraze said: RE said: gg lol. didnt want to look too deep into the argument but this was a reason //takes some time to reread itPhraze said: Don't you agree though? You said in the post right above that Gwen's using wine.RE said: hmm ok. thats so roundaboutPhraze said: It's not reverse psychology, I'm just saying that town!Shinichi has a chance of wanting to out the neighborizer too.RE said: what does reverse psychology have to do with this? its not new.NewG said: So either we're scum for wanting it or we screwed up. Why are you so against the neighborizer coming out? If the neighborizer was scum, they wouldn't want that, would they?RE said: NewG said: That's a very bold statement. It isn't necessary and you can play the game normally, but I think it can help because probability. You'd also do it as uninformed town. The role can just as easily be scum's.RE said: NewG said: Read my reply ^^Read my edit. In that case you're just scaring the neighbourizer away. So, again why point it out, if you yourself are not scum? Because why miss out on a 50/50 percent chance on knowing who is scum, without endangering any of the more useful roles? But WHY call out neighbourizer immediately? Is it necessary? You would only do that as informed scum. Well, if both you and Shin are town then you screwed up already by mentioning it lol See what I did there? That logic can easily be reversed. In the end, it's up them. We'll find out sooner than later, it was a suggestion with probability you can't refute. ok sooo.... u were trying to say that outing neighborizer is NAI, but Gwen was tilting it towards scum motivation, then u pointed out that not outing neighborizer is also NAI and what Gwen is doing =/= she was pot calling kettle black. right? I can understand that. the reverse psychology stuff could go either way for me, since it could be a misunderstanding, but other things stand out to me - Gwen talking philosophy/theory about claims more than poking ppl in her usual town way. Only one it harms claiming is scum if said neighorizer is scum. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: vote me then. What's all this scummy posturing you're doing?logic340 said: @RE logic is anti-bus as mafia if I'm mafia here whisper is town. I'm down with Wisper scum for now tho. oh this perfect even more reason for me to suspect you :D logic340 said: ScarletCelestial said: all I was saying is Mindmelds can lead to easy pocketing. Nothing to do with the work you put in. logic340 said: ScarletCelestial said: I was actually warming tainted...smh.Wisp-O said: ScarletCelestial said: how was the post about u? when logic quoted tainted...Wisp-O said: logic340 said: I dont think we need to worry about tainted getting pocketed... worry about ur lacking posts...Tainted said: Mindmelds are a good way to get yourself pocketed watch yourself. ScarletCelestial said: mindmeld +1Well, I think Gwen has been doing as much mechanical talk as Shin-chan, so I don't know why this is being seen as an indicator. Shin-chan trying to get the Miller to claim is pretty average, though I wouldn't know why they wouldn't come forward themselves. (Of course, I'm using the assumption that Shin-chan had earlier.) Wisp defending his brother is non-alignment indicative really, it probably just means they're the same alignment as I think Wisp tends to have good reads on his brother (or only he is scum trying to trick Shin-chan knowing he is his greatest issue). His actions earlier make me feel kinda weird about him, in a bad way. Shin-chan's massclaim idea, though bad, I feel could come from either alignment. From Town it means it was to get the thread started, from scum to get people to claim early on. The way in which he went about it is what I feel better about. (See my next post.) Those are my thoughts on the brothers (And slightly on Gwen) thus far. like this All the claiming you want would male this hard as invest could die N1. I hate this post, sounds more like scared scum, then concerned townie Wisp, that was directed to me. @NewG sure lol It was directed at me because logic thought I'd get pickpocketed by Tainted's "mindmeld+1". Really? Because I was the one who wrote those thoughts down. Tainted just went and said they had a mindmeld. I was the one who did the work, so I thought you were directing it to me... Town can mindmeld with town, assuming that pocketing attempts may happen is basically ur way of saying that that town should stop reading people for thinking the same as themselves which seems like a scummy suggestion. logic340 said: @RE to answer your question about how Suzu used town!neighbor. She nearly neighbors me (mafia) which would have been all bad for me. She also used her abilkity to have another townie confirm her role when she was almost lynched. It's quite useful for town. Check out Alcatraz d2 if you want to see it for yourself. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: you saw right through me, there is absolutely no fooling you. I guess I should give up now and throw in the towel....logic340 said: @RE there are no thoughts currently as I haven't reread yet? So yes it was answered on my response to tainted who asked for my reads. You asking for a specific read didn't change that... U dont have any current read? WHy do u need to reread to form any sort of read? Are u just trying to think carefully about what ur gonna say since you're scum aligned? logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: you're a joke to me right now... your the one spouting bias shit bro. Get it togetherlogic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: if it was that easy to catch them we would but you know from experience frivolous talk from town helps mafia. You're not a newb i won't accept this from youTainted said: perfect way for scum to out themselves don't u think thrn , if ur in agreement that the scum can easily jump into the conversation why don't we let them then?logic340 said: agree with logic here.Shinichi-Kun said: I'd prefer a possible dichotomy. To each his own...Century_Orion said: Just found out that this is open setup semi open to be exact RE said: vote: Shinichi thiis just random? cause now i am at 3 votes logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: whenever they feel like it, before they would get lynched, massclaim time.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: I agree town shouldn't lie, but that's not what we're discussing. We're talking about proper time to claim Pathetic Fallacy.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: bolded sounds horrible tho. If a fifth vt exists how does coming forward help town? Is that player like IC in it eyes after that? To me the con out weighs the pro.logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: wouldn't this cause harm to potential town pr's?Pathetic Fallacy: Town Named Vanilla I also think if this role exists someone should claim it cause it harms no one for thiis role to be claimed. Outside of narrowing down potential pr, when 4 vanilla townies exist i doubt it. Plus the only other PR in that section is a backup. No not at all, but i dont think town should be lieing about being a vt makes literally no sense for someone thats town to lie about that, it actually harms town. WHich is when? I'll ask you again are the like IC (or maybe mayor) to you if they claim now? If not I'm not really seeing the benefit for town more for scim imo. Of course now but i rather a flavored vanilla be out, before something evil tries to use it against us -.- Let's just stop talking about claiming right now. It's an easy talk for scum to just jump in. Really? Cause i have a slight idea who is scum due to that frivilous talk, i am spotaneous so whatever bias u expect from me is clouding ur judgement. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: jailkeeper has a similar chance of being scum sir. Though you would ve takong a bit of a chance its not completley out of the question. I believe your jailkeeper but which one is the question. Also I wasn't trying to protect one role as I was against both yours and roz's claim suggestions. Why did it take for me to call you out about you own role for you to take action?logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: Why should any of our roles be hidden then? You sound like an as (donkey) I can't even call it scummy anymore maybe just misunderstood. Here is a thought lead by example and claim your role fool.NewG said: I agree with yurkin here. Shinichi is just saying obvious stuff in order to just say stuff. #21 why would a neighbourizer even claim with that high chance in others eyes? Like why mention it? Why put them out like this, if you're not scum? @Shinichi-kun #24 playing the worried in public #22 it harms town (like I already said) Shin is on my suspect list but I want answers first. Toodlez~ edit: added links, added a question why should a role that has a 50\50 chance to be scum not out themselves unless they're scum. #101-why are u reading into the thread and interactions assuming I am scum that's basis for a biased mind set. NewG said: if the wild car is town it be better if we know thst , why should it be hidden from us?NewG said: Shinichi-Kun said: I am gonna start off by saying this now, if a miller doesn claim in the next 24 hours i am gonna assume that slot is taking by the mafia goon, atleast until the wild cards role is known. Not sure if I got the hang of the wild card. Does that mean there are two roles of the same out there? I think I get it now and it just messes everything more up xD Still don't think people should claim voluntarily. I am the town Jail keeper, and why are u using every role as a means to protect 1 role that has a huge chance of being scum aligned I literally dont understand. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: it was meant to accomplish sarcasm....mission accomplished. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: you saw right through me, there is absolutely no fooling you. I guess I should give up now and throw in the towel....logic340 said: @RE there are no thoughts currently as I haven't reread yet? So yes it was answered on my response to tainted who asked for my reads. You asking for a specific read didn't change that... U dont have any current read? WHy do u need to reread to form any sort of read? Are u just trying to think carefully about what ur gonna say since you're scum aligned? What did u feel this sarcastic post would accomplish other than giving people more reasons to think u may be scum. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: I'm not seeing what one has to do with the other here? I give no shits about your claim at this time because it could very well be you're the only jailkeeper and similar to neighborizer it could be something like 50/50. Let's move past your neighbor hunt for now.Also @logic340 what you say about the JK is true Both can exist None Can exist or 1 can exist If u think the scum one exists why arent u supporting me in getting the neighborizer to claim? logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: Why are you making said comparison and how does it prove anything in this game?logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: jailkeeper has a similar chance of being scum sir. Though you would ve takong a bit of a chance its not completley out of the question. I believe your jailkeeper but which one is the question. Also I wasn't trying to protect one role as I was against both yours and roz's claim suggestions. Why did it take for me to call you out about you own role for you to take action?logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: Why should any of our roles be hidden then? You sound like an as (donkey) I can't even call it scummy anymore maybe just misunderstood. Here is a thought lead by example and claim your role fool.NewG said: I agree with yurkin here. Shinichi is just saying obvious stuff in order to just say stuff. #21 why would a neighbourizer even claim with that high chance in others eyes? Like why mention it? Why put them out like this, if you're not scum? @Shinichi-kun #24 playing the worried in public #22 it harms town (like I already said) Shin is on my suspect list but I want answers first. Toodlez~ edit: added links, added a question why should a role that has a 50\50 chance to be scum not out themselves unless they're scum. #101-why are u reading into the thread and interactions assuming I am scum that's basis for a biased mind set. NewG said: if the wild car is town it be better if we know thst , why should it be hidden from us?NewG said: Shinichi-Kun said: I am gonna start off by saying this now, if a miller doesn claim in the next 24 hours i am gonna assume that slot is taking by the mafia goon, atleast until the wild cards role is known. Not sure if I got the hang of the wild card. Does that mean there are two roles of the same out there? I think I get it now and it just messes everything more up xD Still don't think people should claim voluntarily. I am the town Jail keeper, and why are u using every role as a means to protect 1 role that has a huge chance of being scum aligned I literally dont understand. Ur playing at the same game phraze did to me in zero escape lol, she challenged me to claim but when i finally did claim she wined herself into thinking i was scum. I saw no reason to claim before u asked, you asked so i provided do what you will with this information. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: dude your whole neighbor good chance of being scum spiel is fear mongering, don't play coy with me.logic340 said: Does shinichi always fear monger like this? Devil's advocate I remember not straight out fear mongering... WHat fear mongering do u speak of, and I absolutely loving play the devils advocate its so me. logic340 said: Wisp-O said: Don't worry, be happy...may i ask why you must always defend your brother in these games? Is it because he brought you to the club or is it a familial thing?logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: it was meant to accomplish sarcasm....mission accomplished. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: you saw right through me, there is absolutely no fooling you. I guess I should give up now and throw in the towel....logic340 said: @RE there are no thoughts currently as I haven't reread yet? So yes it was answered on my response to tainted who asked for my reads. You asking for a specific read didn't change that... U dont have any current read? WHy do u need to reread to form any sort of read? Are u just trying to think carefully about what ur gonna say since you're scum aligned? What did u feel this sarcastic post would accomplish other than giving people more reasons to think u may be scum. vote: Logic im happy with my vote here logic340 said: Wisp-O said: fair enough proceed my good sir.logic340 said: Wisp-O said: Don't worry, be happy...may i ask why you must always defend your brother in these games? Is it because he brought you to the club or is it a familial thing?logic340 said: ya and it was pointless...Shinichi-Kun said: it was meant to accomplish sarcasm....mission accomplished. logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: you saw right through me, there is absolutely no fooling you. I guess I should give up now and throw in the towel....logic340 said: @RE there are no thoughts currently as I haven't reread yet? So yes it was answered on my response to tainted who asked for my reads. You asking for a specific read didn't change that... U dont have any current read? WHy do u need to reread to form any sort of read? Are u just trying to think carefully about what ur gonna say since you're scum aligned? What did u feel this sarcastic post would accomplish other than giving people more reasons to think u may be scum. vote: Logic im happy with my vote here [quote=logic340 message=54740925][quote=Wisp-O message=54740452][quote=logic340 message=54740426][quote=Wisp-O message=54740371][quote=logic340 message=54740345] Wisp-O said: Don't worry, be halogic340 said: ya and it was pointless...Shinichi-Kun said: logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: you saw right through me, there is absolutely no fooling you. I guess I should give up now and throw in the towel....logic340 said: @RE there are no thoughts currently as I haven't reread yet? So yes it was answered on my response to tainted who asked for my reads. You asking for a specific read didn't change that... U dont have any current read? WHy do u need to reread to form any sort of read? Are u just trying to think carefully about what ur gonna say since you're scum aligned? What did u feel this sarcastic post would accomplish other than giving people more reasons to think u may be scum. vote: Logic im happy with my vote here |
Mar 30, 2018 8:50 AM
#1169
Ok, there's a character limit in posts. Never doing ISO again. Posted the entire thing but MAL deleted which didn't fit, gg |
Mar 30, 2018 8:51 AM
#1170
Wisp-O said: also before u all start speculating, Roz was the miller... this isnt speculation, this is me knowing because I told yall from the start he was town What the fuck is this? lol |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 8:54 AM
#1171
Shinichi-Kun said: Wisp-O said: thought maybe that OP was the janitor, but it didnt hide the role type, so its probably not I wanna know how many people were jailed so we can find out if 2 exists or just 1 which would clearly be the scum jailer You know you can't take back your claim after this right? |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 8:56 AM
#1172
@NewG Explain fine... There wouldn't have been a tie btw, because Karote removed his vote from yurkin. The time stamps are the same minute... and unless you want to dive into the milliseconds or seconds in between there two posts, then that is irrelevant... they both had the same idea in mind What the fuck is this? lol its me telling you that roz was the miller, not the scum in that category... when he is vanilla he doesnt try as hard, if he was scum, he wouldve just claimed vanilla anyways... and he doesnt lurk as scum or TPR roles. |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Mar 30, 2018 8:59 AM
#1173
Wisp-O said: Shinichi-Kun said: I believe from the fact he didnt out, that its the mafia jailorWisp-O said: thought maybe that OP was the janitor, but it didnt hide the role type, so its probably not I wanna know how many people were jailed so we can find out if 2 exists or just 1 which would clearly be the scum jailer Roz wouldve just claimed vanilla, if he was the goon... He did this mass claim once before as vanilla town, and he couldnt make up a fake claim like he usually does because this is an semi open setup... for some reason he likes fake claiming as town His massclaim idea makes sense both as town and scum since he was the hidden one. |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 9:01 AM
#1174
NewG said: no, no mass claim makes sense as scum... and what does being the hidden one have to do with anything?Wisp-O said: Shinichi-Kun said: Wisp-O said: thought maybe that OP was the janitor, but it didnt hide the role type, so its probably not I wanna know how many people were jailed so we can find out if 2 exists or just 1 which would clearly be the scum jailer Roz wouldve just claimed vanilla, if he was the goon... He did this mass claim once before as vanilla town, and he couldnt make up a fake claim like he usually does because this is an semi open setup... for some reason he likes fake claiming as town His massclaim idea makes sense both as town and scum since he was the hidden one. |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Mar 30, 2018 9:07 AM
#1175
Shinichi-Kun said: Wisp-O said: Shinichi-Kun said: Wisp-O said: thought maybe that OP was the janitor, but it didnt hide the role type, so its probably not I wanna know how many people were jailed so we can find out if 2 exists or just 1 which would clearly be the scum jailer Roz wouldve just claimed vanilla, if he was the goon... He did this mass claim once before as vanilla town, and he couldnt make up a fake claim like he usually does because this is an semi open setup... for some reason he likes fake claiming as town I still think the possiblity exist of roz being a mafia goon, logically speaking 1 jailer has to exist seeing as how a vig shot didnt happen and their was no janitor on that kill. So i am certain a mafia jailer exists. Why does everything need to be done the first night? Vig and Janitor are 1-shots. I am certain, no I know a jailor exists, just not sure which one. Wisp knows the answer apparently. |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 9:12 AM
#1176
Wisp-O said: NewG said: no, no mass claim makes sense as scum... and what does being the hidden one have to do with anything?Wisp-O said: Shinichi-Kun said: I believe from the fact he didnt out, that its the mafia jailorWisp-O said: thought maybe that OP was the janitor, but it didnt hide the role type, so its probably not I wanna know how many people were jailed so we can find out if 2 exists or just 1 which would clearly be the scum jailer Roz wouldve just claimed vanilla, if he was the goon... He did this mass claim once before as vanilla town, and he couldnt make up a fake claim like he usually does because this is an semi open setup... for some reason he likes fake claiming as town His massclaim idea makes sense both as town and scum since he was the hidden one. Because no one can prove if you were lying after your flip. Could see town!roz risking this. |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 9:13 AM
#1177
NewG said: why are we using this reason to defend certain people, and attack others... wtf is with this bias...Wisp-O said: NewG said: Wisp-O said: Shinichi-Kun said: I believe from the fact he didnt out, that its the mafia jailorWisp-O said: thought maybe that OP was the janitor, but it didnt hide the role type, so its probably not I wanna know how many people were jailed so we can find out if 2 exists or just 1 which would clearly be the scum jailer Roz wouldve just claimed vanilla, if he was the goon... He did this mass claim once before as vanilla town, and he couldnt make up a fake claim like he usually does because this is an semi open setup... for some reason he likes fake claiming as town His massclaim idea makes sense both as town and scum since he was the hidden one. Because no one can prove if you were lying after your flip. Could see town!roz risking this. |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Mar 30, 2018 9:14 AM
#1178
Shinichi-Kun said: NewG said: SCUMREAD ME NOW BITCHES! Why does being jailed mean u cant be scum read? If Mafia jailer exists all they would need to do is not jail someone so u can claim being jailed. DOnt try to play us like fools Nah, this was a message for scum after my claim. |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 9:19 AM
#1179
Wisp-O said: logic340 said: ....... roz wasnt the goon... instead of wineing urself, choose to listen to me for once, and if there is still a miller alive after that roz lynch, then that would be 7 vanilla towns, if u choose to believe Logic...NewG said: Shinichi-Kun said: NewG said: Shinichi-Kun said: logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: Why vote roxz in the first place then? You created the tie you didn't want?logic340 said: @Shinichi-kun can you explain your thought process in tying the vote 5 minutes before phase change the quick changing it back 1 minute beforei phase change? What there to explain? Did you not read the EOD or are u just playing the part of an idiot XD? I did not want a tie so i voted yurkin, karote then changed his vote roz so therefore i changed my vote back to roz to stop a tie. It seems pretty self explanatory. his lynched seemed like it was gonna happen, or would u have rather u got lynced? NewG said: Worst case scenario for town yea but also worst case scenario for scum with that lynch. Now that the miller or goon is gone. I claim citizen. Gwen ur still scum in my eyes, and the way you provided this claim takes the cake How am I still scum? The baddie is gone What baddie? U mentioned u were only claiming cause the miller is gone, u dont think that sounds suspect in your eye. Because now I know I'm not the miller. So I am free to claim. Don't be salty you can get me maybe next time. White wine edit: this is logic, fuck your avatar 6, not 7 ...but hey who's counting |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 9:21 AM
#1180
Wisp-O said: NewG said: why are we using this reason to defend certain people, and attack others... wtf is with this bias...Wisp-O said: NewG said: no, no mass claim makes sense as scum... and what does being the hidden one have to do with anything?Wisp-O said: Shinichi-Kun said: I believe from the fact he didnt out, that its the mafia jailorWisp-O said: thought maybe that OP was the janitor, but it didnt hide the role type, so its probably not I wanna know how many people were jailed so we can find out if 2 exists or just 1 which would clearly be the scum jailer Roz wouldve just claimed vanilla, if he was the goon... He did this mass claim once before as vanilla town, and he couldnt make up a fake claim like he usually does because this is an semi open setup... for some reason he likes fake claiming as town His massclaim idea makes sense both as town and scum since he was the hidden one. Because no one can prove if you were lying after your flip. Could see town!roz risking this. Looool who am I defending with this? Roz is dead! The most troublesome role for town is gone. If all it's the citizens I am defending. |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 9:32 AM
#1182
ya go to sleep <3 |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Mar 30, 2018 9:36 AM
#1183
NewG said: woops xDWisp-O said: logic340 said: NewG said: Actually...if roz was goon in that category there could still be a Miller due to the wild card. Shinichi-Kun said: NewG said: Shinichi-Kun said: logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: Why vote roxz in the first place then? You created the tie you didn't want?logic340 said: @Shinichi-kun can you explain your thought process in tying the vote 5 minutes before phase change the quick changing it back 1 minute beforei phase change? What there to explain? Did you not read the EOD or are u just playing the part of an idiot XD? I did not want a tie so i voted yurkin, karote then changed his vote roz so therefore i changed my vote back to roz to stop a tie. It seems pretty self explanatory. his lynched seemed like it was gonna happen, or would u have rather u got lynced? NewG said: Worst case scenario for town yea but also worst case scenario for scum with that lynch. Now that the miller or goon is gone. I claim citizen. Gwen ur still scum in my eyes, and the way you provided this claim takes the cake How am I still scum? The baddie is gone What baddie? U mentioned u were only claiming cause the miller is gone, u dont think that sounds suspect in your eye. Because now I know I'm not the miller. So I am free to claim. Don't be salty you can get me maybe next time. White wine edit: this is logic, fuck your avatar 6, not 7 ...but hey who's counting NewG said: just in general not specifically u...Wisp-O said: NewG said: Wisp-O said: NewG said: no, no mass claim makes sense as scum... and what does being the hidden one have to do with anything?Wisp-O said: Shinichi-Kun said: I believe from the fact he didnt out, that its the mafia jailorWisp-O said: thought maybe that OP was the janitor, but it didnt hide the role type, so its probably not I wanna know how many people were jailed so we can find out if 2 exists or just 1 which would clearly be the scum jailer Roz wouldve just claimed vanilla, if he was the goon... He did this mass claim once before as vanilla town, and he couldnt make up a fake claim like he usually does because this is an semi open setup... for some reason he likes fake claiming as town His massclaim idea makes sense both as town and scum since he was the hidden one. Because no one can prove if you were lying after your flip. Could see town!roz risking this. Looool who am I defending with this? Roz is dead! The most troublesome role for town is gone. If all it's the citizens I am defending. probably shouldve explained why I thought there was a confirmed mafia jailor, cause now I cant remember why I came to that conclusion xD... @NewG why do u think you got jailed? |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Mar 30, 2018 9:40 AM
#1184
Nah you turn your brain on or be quiet and go to sleep. I like how this is just a Wisp/Gwen page minus Karote commenting outta nowhere again. So....just the usual. |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 9:41 AM
#1185
Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: Pokeit said: Wisp-O said: Your argument here is odd. You blame him for not keeping his vote on yurkin because there was nothing that said she couldn't be mafia? How about you explain your suspicions towards her and why she's your third vote option.Karote said: nothing says she couldnt? but u were ok with voting Roz who also wasnt really there....Wisp-O said: Karote said: who cares... when she could be scum...NewG said: Guys, don't even try to shade me. Scum would be really stupid to lynch me now, because my flip is telling. @Pokeit Karote said he didnt mind a yurkin train, yet he "saved" her...I'm just gonna see where this goes. I didn't mind train for the pressure if that's what would make her talk but it didn't, didn't want to get her lynched when she was sleeping and had no chance of defense. And explain to me with reasons why she could be scum? Also, @NewG Can you answer #977? Karote is the reason why he suspects yurkin Karote said: Tainted said: Wisp could be scum Gwen could also be scum kinda agree with Phraze there. Don't really have any strong reads but that's where I'm at Tainted said: Anyway if Gwen/Phraze is my top scumreads I will side with Phraze. The two doesn't seem SvS so one of them should be town. Then voted for Wisp at some point. Read all of his posts because could barely notice Tainted and couldn't quite figure out where to put him. He asks pretty general questions .. comments on game stuff. Doesn't particulary attacks anyone or pushes. Vote: Tainted Why you gotta be so neutral? oh now u come up with a good read smh Vote:Tainted Yeah, leave yesterdays people alone for today and sort out others .. If you still think logic is scum then go for it near phase end. As for yurkin, well, I don't see any point voting for an inactive, if she wants to talk then will otherwise leave it to Penta to modkill her if doesn't. WHy leave them alone that doesnt make any sense, what if they're scum? |
Mar 30, 2018 9:42 AM
#1186
Wisp-O said: probably shouldve explained why I thought there was a confirmed mafia jailor, cause now I cant remember why I came to that conclusion xD... @NewG why do u think you got jailed? You forgot? lol I don't think, I know. |
<3 |
Mar 30, 2018 9:42 AM
#1187
Mar 30, 2018 9:42 AM
#1188
NewG said: Phraze said: NewG said: Worst case scenario for town yea but also worst case scenario for scum with that lynch. Now that the miller or goon is gone. I claim citizen. Vote: Taker6898 What's there so hard to understand? The only threat to citizen is gone. You are free, slave! How is my claim not believable when already half of the categories are showcased? But go ahead. Unlike wisp I'm willing to sacrifice myself to lower the PoE Its still stand to be said that the most obvious role claim will be civilian unless scum control multiple scum roles in a flavor group. Whats not to understand about that, claiming vanilla in no way shape or form clears you. |
Mar 30, 2018 9:42 AM
#1189
NewG said: Phraze said: NewG said: Worst case scenario for town yea but also worst case scenario for scum with that lynch. Now that the miller or goon is gone. I claim citizen. Vote: Taker6898 What's there so hard to understand? The only threat to citizen is gone. You are free, slave! How is my claim not believable when already half of the categories are showcased? But go ahead. Unlike wisp I'm willing to sacrifice myself to lower the PoE Its still stand to be said that the most obvious role claim will be civilian unless scum control multiple scum roles in a flavor group. Whats not to understand about that, claiming vanilla in no way shape or form clears you. |
Mar 30, 2018 9:43 AM
#1190
NewG said: no i mean... why do you think you were jailed... lmao like as in why do you think the town or mafia jailor would target you? xDWisp-O said: probably shouldve explained why I thought there was a confirmed mafia jailor, cause now I cant remember why I came to that conclusion xD... @NewG why do u think you got jailed? You forgot? lol I don't think, I know. |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Mar 30, 2018 9:45 AM
#1191
Tainted said: logic340 said: no anyone who got a red peek should be lynch automatically there's no need to let him get a pass for being a miller wildcard.NewG said: Shinichi-Kun said: NewG said: Shinichi-Kun said: logic340 said: Shinichi-Kun said: Why vote roxz in the first place then? You created the tie you didn't want?logic340 said: @Shinichi-kun can you explain your thought process in tying the vote 5 minutes before phase change the quick changing it back 1 minute beforei phase change? What there to explain? Did you not read the EOD or are u just playing the part of an idiot XD? I did not want a tie so i voted yurkin, karote then changed his vote roz so therefore i changed my vote back to roz to stop a tie. It seems pretty self explanatory. his lynched seemed like it was gonna happen, or would u have rather u got lynced? NewG said: Worst case scenario for town yea but also worst case scenario for scum with that lynch. Now that the miller or goon is gone. I claim citizen. Gwen ur still scum in my eyes, and the way you provided this claim takes the cake How am I still scum? The baddie is gone What baddie? U mentioned u were only claiming cause the miller is gone, u dont think that sounds suspect in your eye. Because now I know I'm not the miller. So I am free to claim. Don't be salty you can get me maybe next time. White wine hmm? Tainted said: Wisp-O said: logic was about to be lynched? He's got more than half a day when he claimed..Pokeit said: Wisp-O said: I talk about this in #852.Pokeit said: how is he a town lean, outside his fucking claim... Logic is town-lean, so no. A massclaim would be great right now tho Better to claim early anyways whats your point there, the timing doesnt change much Tainted said: Wisp-O said: everyone could be scum omg wisp is scum.Karote said: NewG said: Guys, don't even try to shade me. Scum would be really stupid to lynch me now, because my flip is telling. @Pokeit Karote said he didnt mind a yurkin train, yet he "saved" her...I'm just gonna see where this goes. I didn't mind train for the pressure if that's what would make her talk but it didn't, didn't want to get her lynched when she was sleeping and had no chance of defense. Tainted u feel so off this game, ur not even giving good reasons as to why u suspect wisp. Change vote:tainted |
Mar 30, 2018 9:50 AM
#1192
Mar 30, 2018 9:51 AM
#1193
Tainted said: Shinichi-Kun said: well I want your brother not gwen.. if we're talking about neutral isn't he more neutral than I am? Did he actually do anything besides pushing for logic?Tainted said: I'm still down for lynching Wisp. Even if wisp is telling the truth we can confirm that he's citizen or not cause there's only one role in his category so the 4 in play will turn to 3. We can lower the poe on citizens that way. then this same logic can be applied to Gwen, I ain't lynching a civilian when there can still be more claimed I mean i rather lynch logic first, because if they're scum together then kyle is powerwolfing logic quite hard which i see no reason for him to do that on day 1. Give me a detail report on why u would rather wisp than gwen Mind you i dont want to vote either of them, gwen was jailed so i am pretty sure shes town i wont wine myself out of that one. Kyle push on logic seems like something town wisp would do in my opinion and the way hes just being biased towards some of this reads. |
Mar 30, 2018 9:53 AM
#1194
Tainted said: Shinichi-Kun said: you just lied and now you're still gonna hide the truth?Tainted said: Shinichi-Kun said: just claim your real roleThat fact that i wasnt jailed or shot means that mafia have scum in the group that the town JK is in. Seeing as how neither happened I dont think a town vigilante exists nor does a town Jail Keeper at this point. Meaning mafia have both in the scenario The question I now ask was anyone actually jailed? Why? Century_Orion said: Just rereading everything from last day (Page 8+) Claiming as neighborizer - haven't used my role yet Didn't like the idea of massclaim - felt that it weeds out town so mafia can have easier kills. That wasn't too hard now was it century, but why didn't u use ur ability? You ain't locktown you don't get a pass for that shit. Who said i lied, all I did was retract my claim What would scum shin gain from retracting a claim that wasnt countered, like seriously try to find actual scummy people dont go for people that have town vibes to them. |
Mar 30, 2018 9:57 AM
#1195
Taker6898 said: Tainted said: Shinichi-Kun said: Tainted said: Shinichi-Kun said: Pokeit said: Wisp-O said: Your argument here is odd. You blame him for not keeping his vote on yurkin because there was nothing that said she couldn't be mafia? How about you explain your suspicions towards her and why she's your third vote option.Karote said: nothing says she couldnt? but u were ok with voting Roz who also wasnt really there....Wisp-O said: Karote said: who cares... when she could be scum...NewG said: Guys, don't even try to shade me. Scum would be really stupid to lynch me now, because my flip is telling. @Pokeit Karote said he didnt mind a yurkin train, yet he "saved" her...I'm just gonna see where this goes. I didn't mind train for the pressure if that's what would make her talk but it didn't, didn't want to get her lynched when she was sleeping and had no chance of defense. And explain to me with reasons why she could be scum? Also, @NewG Can you answer #977? Karote is the reason why he suspects yurkin Karote said: Tainted said: Wisp could be scum Gwen could also be scum kinda agree with Phraze there. Don't really have any strong reads but that's where I'm at Tainted said: Anyway if Gwen/Phraze is my top scumreads I will side with Phraze. The two doesn't seem SvS so one of them should be town. Then voted for Wisp at some point. Read all of his posts because could barely notice Tainted and couldn't quite figure out where to put him. He asks pretty general questions .. comments on game stuff. Doesn't particulary attacks anyone or pushes. Vote: Tainted Why you gotta be so neutral? oh now u come up with a good read smh Vote:Tainted Pokeit said: and these oppurtunistic votes deserves to be lynchedKarote said: Tainted said: Wisp could be scum Gwen could also be scum kinda agree with Phraze there. Don't really have any strong reads but that's where I'm at Tainted said: Anyway if Gwen/Phraze is my top scumreads I will side with Phraze. The two doesn't seem SvS so one of them should be town. Then voted for Wisp at some point. Read all of his posts because could barely notice Tainted and couldn't quite figure out where to put him. He asks pretty general questions .. comments on game stuff. Doesn't particulary attacks anyone or pushes. Vote: Tainted Why you gotta be so neutral? I can get behind this. See my #782 and #857 for my further thoughts on Tainted. Vote: Tainted @Tainted What do you think about logic and his claim? Will you join the train on him? Do you have any solid town reads? His case isn't even that good how are they opportunistic? is that all u can do is shade our vogrd to protect ylurself? And how the things he quoted say something about me being neutral. i think tainted is being abnormally super defensive vote: tainted EVen taker sees it and hes still getting used to the game, that says alot about tainted. logic340 said: Unofficial Vote Count 2.2 Tainted (3): Karote, Shinichi, Pokeit, Taker logic340 (1): Wisp-O, yurkin Taker6898 (1): Phraze Shinichi-kun (1): NewG Not Voting: logic340, Century, Tainted http://itsalmo.st/#lavieennight2 Tainted your in L-2 right now might want to claim something? I almost locked tainted, that would have been quite hilarious seeing as how i was not paying attention Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: Tainted said: Shinichi-Kun said: Pokeit said: Wisp-O said: Your argument here is odd. You blame him for not keeping his vote on yurkin because there was nothing that said she couldn't be mafia? How about you explain your suspicions towards her and why she's your third vote option.Karote said: nothing says she couldnt? but u were ok with voting Roz who also wasnt really there....Wisp-O said: Karote said: who cares... when she could be scum...NewG said: Guys, don't even try to shade me. Scum would be really stupid to lynch me now, because my flip is telling. @Pokeit Karote said he didnt mind a yurkin train, yet he "saved" her...I'm just gonna see where this goes. I didn't mind train for the pressure if that's what would make her talk but it didn't, didn't want to get her lynched when she was sleeping and had no chance of defense. And explain to me with reasons why she could be scum? Also, @NewG Can you answer #977? Karote is the reason why he suspects yurkin Karote said: Tainted said: Wisp could be scum Gwen could also be scum kinda agree with Phraze there. Don't really have any strong reads but that's where I'm at Tainted said: Anyway if Gwen/Phraze is my top scumreads I will side with Phraze. The two doesn't seem SvS so one of them should be town. Then voted for Wisp at some point. Read all of his posts because could barely notice Tainted and couldn't quite figure out where to put him. He asks pretty general questions .. comments on game stuff. Doesn't particulary attacks anyone or pushes. Vote: Tainted Why you gotta be so neutral? oh now u come up with a good read smh Vote:Tainted Pokeit said: and these oppurtunistic votes deserves to be lynchedKarote said: Tainted said: Wisp could be scum Gwen could also be scum kinda agree with Phraze there. Don't really have any strong reads but that's where I'm at Tainted said: Anyway if Gwen/Phraze is my top scumreads I will side with Phraze. The two doesn't seem SvS so one of them should be town. Then voted for Wisp at some point. Read all of his posts because could barely notice Tainted and couldn't quite figure out where to put him. He asks pretty general questions .. comments on game stuff. Doesn't particulary attacks anyone or pushes. Vote: Tainted Why you gotta be so neutral? I can get behind this. See my #782 and #857 for my further thoughts on Tainted. Vote: Tainted @Tainted What do you think about logic and his claim? Will you join the train on him? Do you have any solid town reads? His case isn't even that good how are they opportunistic? is that all u can do is shade our vogrd to protect ylurself? That ain't helping, lol. Hmm? Tainted said: Karote said: you misunderstand I never called you/logic/yurkin scum team.Tainted said: Karote said: smh you're just nitpickingTainted said: Wisp could be scum Gwen could also be scum kinda agree with Phraze there. Don't really have any strong reads but that's where I'm at Tainted said: Anyway if Gwen/Phraze is my top scumreads I will side with Phraze. The two doesn't seem SvS so one of them should be town. Then voted for Wisp at some point. Read all of his posts because could barely notice Tainted and couldn't quite figure out where to put him. He asks pretty general questions .. comments on game stuff. Doesn't particulary attacks anyone or pushes. Vote: Tainted Why you gotta be so neutral? If you isoed me I've been pushing for logic most of the day but since he claimed I just backed off it and voted for wisp instead. Elaborate on the general question stuffs. You didn't quote it No, you didn't push logic most of the day, just asked to sheep him then explained why you thought he was scum because of meta. Voted Wisp without really explaining why then proceed to ask questions to others. I quoted your suspects/votes because they are all over the place, today you call yurkin/me/logic as scum team, in few hours will it be something else? You aren't consistent with that. Tainted said: Taker6898 said: because the case was just that bad. I'm triggered..Tainted said: Shinichi-Kun said: elaborate why his case on me is good.Tainted said: Shinichi-Kun said: Pokeit said: Wisp-O said: Your argument here is odd. You blame him for not keeping his vote on yurkin because there was nothing that said she couldn't be mafia? How about you explain your suspicions towards her and why she's your third vote option.Karote said: nothing says she couldnt? but u were ok with voting Roz who also wasnt really there....Wisp-O said: Karote said: who cares... when she could be scum...NewG said: Guys, don't even try to shade me. Scum would be really stupid to lynch me now, because my flip is telling. @Pokeit Karote said he didnt mind a yurkin train, yet he "saved" her...I'm just gonna see where this goes. I didn't mind train for the pressure if that's what would make her talk but it didn't, didn't want to get her lynched when she was sleeping and had no chance of defense. And explain to me with reasons why she could be scum? Also, @NewG Can you answer #977? Karote is the reason why he suspects yurkin Karote said: Tainted said: Wisp could be scum Gwen could also be scum kinda agree with Phraze there. Don't really have any strong reads but that's where I'm at Tainted said: Anyway if Gwen/Phraze is my top scumreads I will side with Phraze. The two doesn't seem SvS so one of them should be town. Then voted for Wisp at some point. Read all of his posts because could barely notice Tainted and couldn't quite figure out where to put him. He asks pretty general questions .. comments on game stuff. Doesn't particulary attacks anyone or pushes. Vote: Tainted Why you gotta be so neutral? oh now u come up with a good read smh Vote:Tainted Pokeit said: and these oppurtunistic votes deserves to be lynchedKarote said: Tainted said: Wisp could be scum Gwen could also be scum kinda agree with Phraze there. Don't really have any strong reads but that's where I'm at Tainted said: Anyway if Gwen/Phraze is my top scumreads I will side with Phraze. The two doesn't seem SvS so one of them should be town. Then voted for Wisp at some point. Read all of his posts because could barely notice Tainted and couldn't quite figure out where to put him. He asks pretty general questions .. comments on game stuff. Doesn't particulary attacks anyone or pushes. Vote: Tainted Why you gotta be so neutral? I can get behind this. See my #782 and #857 for my further thoughts on Tainted. Vote: Tainted @Tainted What do you think about logic and his claim? Will you join the train on him? Do you have any solid town reads? His case isn't even that good how are they opportunistic? is that all u can do is shade our vogrd to protect ylurself? And how the things he quoted say something about me being neutral. i think tainted is being abnormally super defensive vote: tainted It's not even a case, I'm not calling you out to be scum, I'm asking why you play that way so I can get a better read on you because you're really NEUTRAL to me, what's so hard to understand about that. Who's your biggest scumread and townread? Just iso wisp he's obviously scum he's so bad he haven't really done much and his pushes doesn't even sound real I don't get the feeling that he's scum hunting just pushing for a lynch on logic. Honestly if jester was in this game i would say ur a jester |
Mar 30, 2018 10:00 AM
#1196
Shinichi-Kun said: Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: Pokeit said: Wisp-O said: Your argument here is odd. You blame him for not keeping his vote on yurkin because there was nothing that said she couldn't be mafia? How about you explain your suspicions towards her and why she's your third vote option.Karote said: nothing says she couldnt? but u were ok with voting Roz who also wasnt really there....Wisp-O said: Karote said: who cares... when she could be scum...NewG said: Guys, don't even try to shade me. Scum would be really stupid to lynch me now, because my flip is telling. @Pokeit Karote said he didnt mind a yurkin train, yet he "saved" her...I'm just gonna see where this goes. I didn't mind train for the pressure if that's what would make her talk but it didn't, didn't want to get her lynched when she was sleeping and had no chance of defense. And explain to me with reasons why she could be scum? Also, @NewG Can you answer #977? Karote is the reason why he suspects yurkin Karote said: Tainted said: Wisp could be scum Gwen could also be scum kinda agree with Phraze there. Don't really have any strong reads but that's where I'm at Tainted said: Anyway if Gwen/Phraze is my top scumreads I will side with Phraze. The two doesn't seem SvS so one of them should be town. Then voted for Wisp at some point. Read all of his posts because could barely notice Tainted and couldn't quite figure out where to put him. He asks pretty general questions .. comments on game stuff. Doesn't particulary attacks anyone or pushes. Vote: Tainted Why you gotta be so neutral? oh now u come up with a good read smh Vote:Tainted Yeah, leave yesterdays people alone for today and sort out others .. If you still think logic is scum then go for it near phase end. As for yurkin, well, I don't see any point voting for an inactive, if she wants to talk then will otherwise leave it to Penta to modkill her if doesn't. WHy leave them alone that doesnt make any sense, what if they're scum? Makes no sense cus you didn't get what I'm trying to say. Stop focusing same ppl as last day and sort out others, if you still want go for your original scumreads then do so but later ok? |
Mar 30, 2018 10:01 AM
#1197
I am town Sadly I think wisp is town...stuck in a tunnel but town. Phraze/Pokeit/Karote are town leans With no counter to Shinichi's fake claim plus gwen being jailed I believe jailed is mafia meaning gwen for town This leaves Shinichi/yurkin/century/taker/tainted I'm willing to vote any of thrm as i feel these 5 is where I think we'll find scum That claim doesn't feel fake but there's not enough for me to say he's certain town Shinichi idk what to make of him I'll reread his D2 Yurkin has been very standoffish this game and give little to no reasoning for her suspicions o her vote Taker is new butni not getting inquisitive new town vibes. That being said he surely doesn't feel coached Tainted more presence than yurkin but similar vibe as he does not explain much when starting his reads |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Mar 30, 2018 10:01 AM
#1198
WHat makes u think that? logic340 said: it's the only sensible conclusion I can come to for a town!shinichi. Otherwise he's likely scum here. If u think thats the case why are u voting me? Instead of pushing me when u know i was obviously messing around shouldnt u be trying to find scum instead of ruining what i was trying to use to catch scum. Wisp-O said: U people are making more wine for scum.... @shinichi-kun just claim so we can lynch logic And I told u this was gunna happen... Sigh u all suck i am the town jker, I was trying to read out the mafia role in this category but apparently ur all to hung up on me to have noticed that. Yes i jailed gwen and yes she is town. |
Mar 30, 2018 10:02 AM
#1199
NewG said: yurkin said: Gwen #966 "Because now I know I'm not the miller. So I am free to claim. Don't be salty you can get me maybe next time" There is only two roles in that category. You basically claimed goon. And jailkeeper can easily protect a buddy if they fear vig kill. I'm fine with voting either gwen or logic today. Those Who Hide (1 in play) Why are people so ignorant about the set-up? wild card -.- |
Mar 30, 2018 10:03 AM
#1200
Wisp-O said: NewG said: I believe Roz was the miller, and if choose to go that route, then there is 6 vanilla this game... which I don't know if that's normal for a setup this size tbh, I really need to look more into it.Yup, it'll help in the longer run And logics and chads claim should fall under the same bout, if logic was taking a risk to claim, then so was shin, so why is it more likely that shin is scum? Why even put himself under that pressure, why even take back his claim, it would be better to just stick with your lie if you were sxum. Logically, I believe shin was trying to figure out who was scum in that category... If someone claims jailkeeper now, they are most def scum FUCKING THANK YOU, atleast my own brother understands god damn why cant u all be smart like him and just overall logical. |
More topics from this board
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8752 |
by Aswin_Ash
»»
Jan 23, 11:52 AM |
|
» Chat Thread ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Fo - Jul 10, 2014 |
3741 |
by Jackrito
»»
Jan 11, 3:55 PM |
|
» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Lambtron - May 15, 2018 |
1161 |
by Jackrito
»»
Jan 9, 8:12 AM |
|
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2870 |
by Jackrito
»»
Jan 8, 11:22 AM |
|
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated MEMBER Posts! v1 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SoulEaterQUEEN - Mar 26, 2016 |
1990 |
by Serafos
»»
Aug 17, 2024 9:42 PM |