10 - Masterpiece - This does not mean the series is of perfection, it simply indicates a series that has left a powerful impact on me. A series that leaves me thinking for quite a while upon finishing. A series that presents something beautiful to me that no other work in any story-telling medium could possibly re-create. A series that leaves me feeling hollow in the best bittersweet way possible. A series that will stand the test of time.
9 - Fantastic - A series that didn't quite leave a huge impact or had too many shortcomings to garner a 10, but not enough to bring the series down as a whole. A series that is brilliantly crafted. A series that is intellectually and emotionally gripping, rather than manipulative. A series that succeeds in what it tries to accomplish and accomplishes it very well. A series that breaks most boundaries.
8 - Great - A series that doesn't quite reach its potential and is brought down by some glaring flaws, but is a still far above from simply being "good". A series that holds something of value. A series that is well worth your time
7 - Good - A series that is neither truly special nor remarkable, but enjoyable nonetheless. A series that succeeds in most areas. A series that doesn't take enough risks, but sticks to what it does best and does it fairly well. A series that is likeable, but not loveable.
6 - Above Par - A series where its pros just barely outweigh the cons, but not enough to be of any true worth. A series that has limited appeal. A series that squanders most of its potential. A series that is ambitious but severely lacking refinement
5 - Indifferent - A series that is neither amazing nor terrible. A series that has its brilliant moments along with a good share of insufferable moments. A series that is simply forgettable
4 - Bad - A series that is silly and contrived. A series that either over performs or under performs. A series that falls flat on its face too many times. A series that isn't bad enough to become intolerable, but is essentially still a waste of time
3 - Poor - A series that only has one or two minor redeeming qualities. A series that is poorly executed. A series plagued with too many missteps and and imperfections. A series that doesn't try hard enough or tries too hard enough to result in an overly pretentious mess.
2 - Awful - A series that misses the mark every time. A series that fails to even be remotely engaging or thought-provoking. A series that is detrimental to the mind. A series that makes you scratch your head in frustrating bewilderment.
I try my best with the reviews I write. I'm not the best writer here on MAL, but I actually do put effort into my reviews. I appreciate your input though.
And I disagree with that quote you gave. While it may seems like a harem, those "plot-devices" were used for Kirito's development. It's not as superficial as Reckoner portrays.
White Album 2 is quite fantastic. I went in with a low expectation but the music, the character monologue, and the gentle yet lively atmosphere in episode one made this series a must continue.
To kick off, what are your favourite and least favourite genres?
All Comments (19) Comments
And I disagree with that quote you gave. While it may seems like a harem, those "plot-devices" were used for Kirito's development. It's not as superficial as Reckoner portrays.
To kick off, what are your favourite and least favourite genres?
sorry for responding so late
and yeah, the last ep is basically a lesson in how not to do everything, literally
you really won't regret it. The show is an unmemorable pile of shit unless you finish it. If so, then it's a memorable pile of shit.
You can even skip through the middle episodes
(Does that mean you read my blog?)
like really that last episode will give you something to think about