New
Jan 25, 2018 8:36 PM
#1201
I dont have to defend myself @lastwhisper more important things than that, you have to prove to others I am scum even though i am town. |
Jan 25, 2018 8:36 PM
#1203
Shinichi-Kun said: misreading again, I said that about abhu not you...lastwhisper31 said: @re1031 well the fact that she brought up that her vote was RVS, kinda makes me feel like she is town, because idk seems like she would let it slide if she was scum because i just pocketed myself... Her vote was obviously rvs tho so not quite sure what her bringing it up has to do with anything? Btw u changed ur vote before i even got to reply whats wrong? lastwhisper31 said: Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: Pokeit said: Are masons always town-alligned? Or is there a possibility that one of them is scum? Not always but i aint sure if thats considered a bastard role if its done like that. Why aren't you outing your other mason? Where did i imply i was ok dieing, and on top of that its my claim not sure what else to say XD. Shinichi-Kun said: dont worry about why I changed my vote, in 14 hours my vote will be back on you at the rate this is goinglastwhisper31 said: @re1031 well the fact that she brought up that her vote was RVS, kinda makes me feel like she is town, because idk seems like she would let it slide if she was scum because i just pocketed myself... Her vote was obviously rvs tho so not quite sure what her bringing it up has to do with anything? Btw u changed ur vote before i even got to reply whats wrong? lastwhisper31 said: Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: Pokeit said: Are masons always town-alligned? Or is there a possibility that one of them is scum? Not always but i aint sure if thats considered a bastard role if its done like that. Why aren't you outing your other mason? Where did i imply i was ok dieing, and on top of that its my claim not sure what else to say XD. |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Jan 25, 2018 8:37 PM
#1204
Shinichi-Kun said: liar............................................... such a liar....................................... burn it at the sakeRuu said: lastwhisper31 said: Ruu said: tbh whats your opinion on both their EoD claims? Im curious...this thread is so dead... @abhutrash @Shinichi-Kun are you gonna keep your votes on Togs? What do you guys think of logic? I think abhu's claim is more believable than Chad's. He thought he was had died so there was no need to fake claim. Masons, on the other hand, is a great fake claim that has been used by the mafia. I want to know who is this famous partner of his. That will tell us if this claim is true or not. I dont fake claim i suck at it, i am the kind of person even if i am sucm roleblocker ill just claim roleblocker an pray. This is my role and I am town, I didnt want to even have to claim but if i was going to i wouldnt have done it at the last minute. I thought doing it an hour before phase change gave people plenty of oppurutunity took look over it. |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Jan 25, 2018 8:38 PM
#1205
Shinichi-Kun said: I dont have to defend myself @lastwhisper more important things than that, you have to prove to others I am scum even though i am town. Innocent until proven otherwise? Not how it works here, it's guilty until proven otherwise :^) |
Jan 25, 2018 8:38 PM
#1206
Ruu said: abhutrash said: Ruu said: lastwhisper31 said: RE1031 said: I dont agree with everything Ruu does or says, but I do agree after thinking about it, that masons claims are a pretty good safety net for scum, and meta wise I've seen some of Chad role claims, and even with the day phase rolling to an end, it still doesn't feel like a town role claim. I do agree, having a secret mason would be helpful, but with chad being consistently scummy it wouldnt even matter, and whose to say that when the other person claims, that he isnt just as scummy either, its not like when he claims, that all of their scuminess will just be gone with the wind. and we look at how they interact outside their private chat, and who the other player is could say a lot... I understand why you feel it would be better, but in the case of Chad, like I said, he has 24 hours from that post this afternoon to give me a reason hes not scum... Ruu said: I just feel super uncomfortable with this. On one hand, if he's mafia, then yeah, we want his partner to claim so they can be put on the peek list to see if they're both really town. On the other, having a secret mason can be really helpful especially late game because that's one person we know not to lynch.abhutrash said: Also, whoever is Shin's supposed mason partner should really step up. The claim is getting less and less convincing by the hour. +1 Also, even if someone else claims, what do we do then? Do we believe the claim or is there going to be some way of testing it? My question is basically how would a partner coming out to claim change whether we believe it or not. the bolded part is why I want him to claim. If his partner is someone I was townreading I will rethink the whole thing and might help me see his posts in a different way. I think I have an idea on who this misterious partner could be and I'm waiting for them to confirm it. Explain to me why a secret mason is better than two confirmed townies. @RE1031 I think you are contradicting yourself with this post and the previous one. Why I want Shin's partner to claim? - I think Shin is mafia and he is fake claiming - if his partner confirms his claim we might get two confirmed townies (or we could find another mafia, it all depends) - what's better? to lynch Shin now and find out his alignment and if he is town confirmed his claim or get two confirmed townies and lynch scum thanks to a better town block? -One thing i want to understand since its been bothering me alot, why do u believe its a fake claim and that I aint just scum mason? -I dont want 2 confirmed townies I want mafia to risk shooting my mason buddy -Ur already under a bias assumption because ur assuming if I am town then my buddy is town which honestly shouldnt be the case. |
Jan 25, 2018 8:39 PM
#1207
Shinichi-Kun said: dont worry about everyone else, u need to prove to me you are not scum, or you will face the consequences tomorrow, and enough people think your scum... idk what you meanI dont have to defend myself @lastwhisper more important things than that, you have to prove to others I am scum even though i am town. |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Jan 25, 2018 8:39 PM
#1208
Karote said: LOLOLShinichi-Kun said: I dont have to defend myself @lastwhisper more important things than that, you have to prove to others I am scum even though i am town. Innocent until proven otherwise? Not how it works here, it's guilty until proven otherwise :^) |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Jan 25, 2018 8:40 PM
#1209
Shinichi-Kun said: THESE POSTS ARE SO BAD LOL.... @karote get ur ass back over hereRuu said: abhutrash said: Ruu said: A second person claiming mason wouldn't fully confirm for town tho. For all we know, there might not be masons in the game.lastwhisper31 said: RE1031 said: I dont agree with everything Ruu does or says, but I do agree after thinking about it, that masons claims are a pretty good safety net for scum, and meta wise I've seen some of Chad role claims, and even with the day phase rolling to an end, it still doesn't feel like a town role claim. I do agree, having a secret mason would be helpful, but with chad being consistently scummy it wouldnt even matter, and whose to say that when the other person claims, that he isnt just as scummy either, its not like when he claims, that all of their scuminess will just be gone with the wind. and we look at how they interact outside their private chat, and who the other player is could say a lot... I understand why you feel it would be better, but in the case of Chad, like I said, he has 24 hours from that post this afternoon to give me a reason hes not scum... Ruu said: I just feel super uncomfortable with this. On one hand, if he's mafia, then yeah, we want his partner to claim so they can be put on the peek list to see if they're both really town. On the other, having a secret mason can be really helpful especially late game because that's one person we know not to lynch.abhutrash said: Also, whoever is Shin's supposed mason partner should really step up. The claim is getting less and less convincing by the hour. +1 Also, even if someone else claims, what do we do then? Do we believe the claim or is there going to be some way of testing it? My question is basically how would a partner coming out to claim change whether we believe it or not. the bolded part is why I want him to claim. If his partner is someone I was townreading I will rethink the whole thing and might help me see his posts in a different way. I think I have an idea on who this misterious partner could be and I'm waiting for them to confirm it. Explain to me why a secret mason is better than two confirmed townies. @RE1031 I think you are contradicting yourself with this post and the previous one. Why I want Shin's partner to claim? - I think Shin is mafia and he is fake claiming - if his partner confirms his claim we might get two confirmed townies (or we could find another mafia, it all depends) - what's better? to lynch Shin now and find out his alignment and if he is town confirmed his claim or get two confirmed townies and lynch scum thanks to a better town block? -One thing i want to understand since its been bothering me alot, why do u believe its a fake claim and that I aint just scum mason? -I dont want 2 confirmed townies I want mafia to risk shooting my mason buddy -Ur already under a bias assumption because ur assuming if I am town then my buddy is town which honestly shouldnt be the case. |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Jan 25, 2018 8:40 PM
#1210
Shinichi-Kun said: I mean, if you are town, you wouldn't be lying about being a mason...right?abhutrash said: RE1031 said: Ruu said: I just feel super uncomfortable with this. On one hand, if he's mafia, then yeah, we want his partner to claim so they can be put on the peek list to see if they're both really town. On the other, having a secret mason can be really helpful especially late game because that's one person we know not to lynch.abhutrash said: Also, whoever is Shin's supposed mason partner should really step up. The claim is getting less and less convincing by the hour. +1 Also, even if someone else claims, what do we do then? Do we believe the claim or is there going to be some way of testing it? My question is basically how would a partner coming out to claim change whether we believe it or not. Only thing that would complicate this approach would be if Tainted actually was the other mason. I doubt it, but its still is a possibility. Did i reason something wrong? How does me dieing and flipping town confirm the existence of another mason? I just curious seeing as how my role isnt show on death. I mean people can argue all day for me to out my partner but ultiamtely the decision is up to them not me. Also, I agree that you have no responsibility to out your mason friend, that's on them. wisp is the one saying you should. |
Jan 25, 2018 8:40 PM
#1211
Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: I dont wanna give anyone free clears is all, outside of pokeit its hard to see some people as town maybe riku if hes not lieing obviously So who is scum for you? Who do you want to lynch today? ill get back to you on this, but a slight answer is that ur one of the people i suspect. |
Jan 25, 2018 8:42 PM
#1212
abhutrash said: Shinichi-Kun said: Yeah, it is kinda weird how you were listed as possible scum in Scarlet's yurkin ISO, then she says that... In general, the amount of people called confirmed townies here was concerning. As far as I see it, the only person who's truly confirmed is Pokeit.ScarletCelestial said: abhutrash said: @Pokeit Could you give us your current alignment reads when you get the chance? As a conf town, they should give some useful insight. riku, too and probably Shin. At least by the end of the Night phase. Mainly because confirmed Townies have more chance of death. ash, you too, especially because you're Vigilante. Flattered to be called confirm townie but at the same time i feel like i am being pocketed which worries me. Only 1 person should be confirmed which is pokeit so ya its quite conerning to say the least, scarlet has been worrying me and not sure why kyle thinks shes confirmed townie based on an rvs vote. |
Jan 25, 2018 8:43 PM
#1213
Shinichi-Kun said: i dont think ur understanding what I am saying... let me reiterate this for you...Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: I dont wanna give anyone free clears is all, outside of pokeit its hard to see some people as town maybe riku if hes not lieing obviously So who is scum for you? Who do you want to lynch today? ill get back to you on this, but a slight answer is that ur one of the people i suspect. YOU HAVE 24 HOURS TO PROVE TO ME YOU ARE NOT SCUM, OR else YOU WILL FACE MY FURY... ok? |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Jan 25, 2018 8:43 PM
#1214
Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: this stuff. lemme look some more edit--why didnt anyone question her again? smh eh. Im back to square 1 Karote said: And why didn't you? : D I thought she played like always, sharing her thoughts time to time and playing lowkey. Didn't felt anything worthy to attack her for. Shinichi said: I mean u could have always pressured her all of us could have instead of just letting her hide away. Idk, yurkin is that type of player you don't really notice until you need sort out PoE, lmao. Shinichi-Kun said: Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: Pokeit said: Are masons always town-alligned? Or is there a possibility that one of them is scum? Not always but i aint sure if thats considered a bastard role if its done like that. Why aren't you outing your other mason? why should I? U want me to narrow down the targets for mafia to nk? Why are you so worried about that? lol It narrows down the PoE and it hurts mafia more anyway if town has 2 more confirmed townies. We benefit more than scum does. Not true cause i cant confirm the alignment of my buddy only myself, my role pm says nothing about my buddy having to be town. I dont want to give a false premise and i def dont want to risk confining my partner to death. |
Jan 25, 2018 8:45 PM
#1215
lastwhisper31 said: I love how needlessly dramatic you are, it's quite entertaining lolShinichi-Kun said: i dont think ur understanding what I am saying... let me reiterate this for you...Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: I dont wanna give anyone free clears is all, outside of pokeit its hard to see some people as town maybe riku if hes not lieing obviously So who is scum for you? Who do you want to lynch today? ill get back to you on this, but a slight answer is that ur one of the people i suspect. YOU HAVE 24 HOURS TO PROVE TO ME YOU ARE NOT SCUM, OR else YOU WILL FACE MY FURY... ok? |
Jan 25, 2018 8:45 PM
#1216
lastwhisper31 said: EoD Votes Analysis:
Conclusion: Abhu is town Shin is still probably scum Logic is most likely scum Ironace is most likely scum… GG I solved the game, everybody go home Assumed ties were no lynch because thats literally how ties are suppose to be resolved and 2nd I barely vote on d1 outside of rvs and stopping a tie so idk what weird meta read you have on me but its quite inaccurate. |
Jan 25, 2018 8:46 PM
#1217
lastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: i dont think ur role is scum aligned, i think you are scum and that role claim is a lie, I think you are scum because of the way you've been playing this game...lastwhisper31 said: vote: Shin u have 24 hours to prove to me you are town, w/o using your claim... @shinichi-kun More curious to know why u think i am scum and why u think my role is scum aligned. my thats my role, and i dont feel like i am playing any differently your just trying to turn me into to something i am not is all. |
Jan 25, 2018 8:46 PM
#1218
abhutrash said: well i need him to understand how serious this is... and hes not getting it... he still keeps focusing on others... and ignoring melastwhisper31 said: I love how needlessly dramatic you are, it's quite entertaining lolShinichi-Kun said: Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: I dont wanna give anyone free clears is all, outside of pokeit its hard to see some people as town maybe riku if hes not lieing obviously So who is scum for you? Who do you want to lynch today? ill get back to you on this, but a slight answer is that ur one of the people i suspect. YOU HAVE 24 HOURS TO PROVE TO ME YOU ARE NOT SCUM, OR else YOU WILL FACE MY FURY... ok? |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Jan 25, 2018 8:47 PM
#1219
Shinichi-Kun said: you do that yourself... cause your posts can be just as bad as Ruu's most of the timelastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: lastwhisper31 said: vote: Shin u have 24 hours to prove to me you are town, w/o using your claim... @shinichi-kun More curious to know why u think i am scum and why u think my role is scum aligned. my thats my role, and i dont feel like i am playing any differently your just trying to turn me into to something i am not is all. |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Jan 25, 2018 8:47 PM
#1220
lastwhisper31 said: abhutrash said: i wish I was a day vig so I could shoot you right now...Shinichi-Kun said: ScarletCelestial said: abhutrash said: @Pokeit Could you give us your current alignment reads when you get the chance? As a conf town, they should give some useful insight. riku, too and probably Shin. At least by the end of the Night phase. Mainly because confirmed Townies have more chance of death. ash, you too, especially because you're Vigilante. Flattered to be called confirm townie but at the same time i feel like i am being pocketed which worries me. is he not correct in what he's saying? |
Jan 25, 2018 8:48 PM
#1221
lastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: THESE POSTS ARE SO BAD LOL.... @karote get ur ass back over hereRuu said: abhutrash said: Ruu said: A second person claiming mason wouldn't fully confirm for town tho. For all we know, there might not be masons in the game.lastwhisper31 said: RE1031 said: I dont agree with everything Ruu does or says, but I do agree after thinking about it, that masons claims are a pretty good safety net for scum, and meta wise I've seen some of Chad role claims, and even with the day phase rolling to an end, it still doesn't feel like a town role claim. I do agree, having a secret mason would be helpful, but with chad being consistently scummy it wouldnt even matter, and whose to say that when the other person claims, that he isnt just as scummy either, its not like when he claims, that all of their scuminess will just be gone with the wind. and we look at how they interact outside their private chat, and who the other player is could say a lot... I understand why you feel it would be better, but in the case of Chad, like I said, he has 24 hours from that post this afternoon to give me a reason hes not scum... Ruu said: I just feel super uncomfortable with this. On one hand, if he's mafia, then yeah, we want his partner to claim so they can be put on the peek list to see if they're both really town. On the other, having a secret mason can be really helpful especially late game because that's one person we know not to lynch.abhutrash said: Also, whoever is Shin's supposed mason partner should really step up. The claim is getting less and less convincing by the hour. +1 Also, even if someone else claims, what do we do then? Do we believe the claim or is there going to be some way of testing it? My question is basically how would a partner coming out to claim change whether we believe it or not. the bolded part is why I want him to claim. If his partner is someone I was townreading I will rethink the whole thing and might help me see his posts in a different way. I think I have an idea on who this misterious partner could be and I'm waiting for them to confirm it. Explain to me why a secret mason is better than two confirmed townies. @RE1031 I think you are contradicting yourself with this post and the previous one. Why I want Shin's partner to claim? - I think Shin is mafia and he is fake claiming - if his partner confirms his claim we might get two confirmed townies (or we could find another mafia, it all depends) - what's better? to lynch Shin now and find out his alignment and if he is town confirmed his claim or get two confirmed townies and lynch scum thanks to a better town block? -One thing i want to understand since its been bothering me alot, why do u believe its a fake claim and that I aint just scum mason? -I dont want 2 confirmed townies I want mafia to risk shooting my mason buddy -Ur already under a bias assumption because ur assuming if I am town then my buddy is town which honestly shouldnt be the case. IM FUCKING DEAD ROFL Idk what he's defending against anymore |
Jan 25, 2018 8:48 PM
#1222
lastwhisper31 said: So not only do u believe i am lieing about my claim which i aint u have some biased belief my mason buddy is scum with me?lol, no, I dont think ur mason, so you have no buddy... your scum partner doesnt need to be mason to claim mason with you... thats my point, stop acting like you dont understand what I am saying I am a mason and my buddy is clearly real I dont fake claim, i aint confident enough to come up with fake claims |
Jan 25, 2018 8:49 PM
#1223
lastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: liar............................................... such a liar....................................... burn it at the sakeRuu said: lastwhisper31 said: Ruu said: tbh whats your opinion on both their EoD claims? Im curious...this thread is so dead... @abhutrash @Shinichi-Kun are you gonna keep your votes on Togs? What do you guys think of logic? I think abhu's claim is more believable than Chad's. He thought he was had died so there was no need to fake claim. Masons, on the other hand, is a great fake claim that has been used by the mafia. I want to know who is this famous partner of his. That will tell us if this claim is true or not. I dont fake claim i suck at it, i am the kind of person even if i am sucm roleblocker ill just claim roleblocker an pray. This is my role and I am town, I didnt want to even have to claim but if i was going to i wouldnt have done it at the last minute. I thought doing it an hour before phase change gave people plenty of oppurutunity took look over it. Find a game where i made up a claim u will never find one cause i dont fake claim |
Jan 25, 2018 8:49 PM
#1224
Shinichi-Kun said: you are such a liar.......................... holy shitlastwhisper31 said: So not only do u believe i am lieing about my claim which i aint u have some biased belief my mason buddy is scum with me?lol, no, I dont think ur mason, so you have no buddy... your scum partner doesnt need to be mason to claim mason with you... thats my point, stop acting like you dont understand what I am saying I am a mason and my buddy is clearly real I dont fake claim, i aint confident enough to come up with fake claims idk if I can even wait 24 hours... |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Jan 25, 2018 8:50 PM
#1225
Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: I dont have to defend myself @lastwhisper more important things than that, you have to prove to others I am scum even though i am town. Innocent until proven otherwise? Not how it works here, it's guilty until proven otherwise :^) I am always innocent espically in this game if you want my buddy to claim your welcome to ask him. |
Jan 25, 2018 8:51 PM
#1226
Shinichi-Kun said: lastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: Ruu said: lastwhisper31 said: Ruu said: tbh whats your opinion on both their EoD claims? Im curious...this thread is so dead... @abhutrash @Shinichi-Kun are you gonna keep your votes on Togs? What do you guys think of logic? I think abhu's claim is more believable than Chad's. He thought he was had died so there was no need to fake claim. Masons, on the other hand, is a great fake claim that has been used by the mafia. I want to know who is this famous partner of his. That will tell us if this claim is true or not. I dont fake claim i suck at it, i am the kind of person even if i am sucm roleblocker ill just claim roleblocker an pray. This is my role and I am town, I didnt want to even have to claim but if i was going to i wouldnt have done it at the last minute. I thought doing it an hour before phase change gave people plenty of oppurutunity took look over it. Find a game where i made up a claim u will never find one cause i dont fake claim Doesn't mean you can't improvise and make up claim here. |
Jan 25, 2018 8:51 PM
#1227
Shinichi-Kun said: you want me to find the game(s), do you really wanna go there? cause there aint no going back after that... and if your town, you dug your own gravelastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: Ruu said: lastwhisper31 said: Ruu said: tbh whats your opinion on both their EoD claims? Im curious...this thread is so dead... @abhutrash @Shinichi-Kun are you gonna keep your votes on Togs? What do you guys think of logic? I think abhu's claim is more believable than Chad's. He thought he was had died so there was no need to fake claim. Masons, on the other hand, is a great fake claim that has been used by the mafia. I want to know who is this famous partner of his. That will tell us if this claim is true or not. I dont fake claim i suck at it, i am the kind of person even if i am sucm roleblocker ill just claim roleblocker an pray. This is my role and I am town, I didnt want to even have to claim but if i was going to i wouldnt have done it at the last minute. I thought doing it an hour before phase change gave people plenty of oppurutunity took look over it. Find a game where i made up a claim u will never find one cause i dont fake claim |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Jan 25, 2018 8:52 PM
#1228
lastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: dont worry about everyone else, u need to prove to me you are not scum, or you will face the consequences tomorrow, and enough people think your scum... idk what you meanI dont have to defend myself @lastwhisper more important things than that, you have to prove to others I am scum even though i am town. Like i care ill just flip town at death lastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: THESE POSTS ARE SO BAD LOL.... @karote get ur ass back over hereRuu said: abhutrash said: Ruu said: A second person claiming mason wouldn't fully confirm for town tho. For all we know, there might not be masons in the game.lastwhisper31 said: RE1031 said: I dont agree with everything Ruu does or says, but I do agree after thinking about it, that masons claims are a pretty good safety net for scum, and meta wise I've seen some of Chad role claims, and even with the day phase rolling to an end, it still doesn't feel like a town role claim. I do agree, having a secret mason would be helpful, but with chad being consistently scummy it wouldnt even matter, and whose to say that when the other person claims, that he isnt just as scummy either, its not like when he claims, that all of their scuminess will just be gone with the wind. and we look at how they interact outside their private chat, and who the other player is could say a lot... I understand why you feel it would be better, but in the case of Chad, like I said, he has 24 hours from that post this afternoon to give me a reason hes not scum... Ruu said: I just feel super uncomfortable with this. On one hand, if he's mafia, then yeah, we want his partner to claim so they can be put on the peek list to see if they're both really town. On the other, having a secret mason can be really helpful especially late game because that's one person we know not to lynch.abhutrash said: Also, whoever is Shin's supposed mason partner should really step up. The claim is getting less and less convincing by the hour. +1 Also, even if someone else claims, what do we do then? Do we believe the claim or is there going to be some way of testing it? My question is basically how would a partner coming out to claim change whether we believe it or not. the bolded part is why I want him to claim. If his partner is someone I was townreading I will rethink the whole thing and might help me see his posts in a different way. I think I have an idea on who this misterious partner could be and I'm waiting for them to confirm it. Explain to me why a secret mason is better than two confirmed townies. @RE1031 I think you are contradicting yourself with this post and the previous one. Why I want Shin's partner to claim? - I think Shin is mafia and he is fake claiming - if his partner confirms his claim we might get two confirmed townies (or we could find another mafia, it all depends) - what's better? to lynch Shin now and find out his alignment and if he is town confirmed his claim or get two confirmed townies and lynch scum thanks to a better town block? -One thing i want to understand since its been bothering me alot, why do u believe its a fake claim and that I aint just scum mason? -I dont want 2 confirmed townies I want mafia to risk shooting my mason buddy -Ur already under a bias assumption because ur assuming if I am town then my buddy is town which honestly shouldnt be the case. Ur not properly replying to my posts so of course i see no reason to defend myself |
Jan 25, 2018 8:52 PM
#1229
Shinichi-Kun said: I'd ask him, but idk who he is so..............Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: I dont have to defend myself @lastwhisper more important things than that, you have to prove to others I am scum even though i am town. Innocent until proven otherwise? Not how it works here, it's guilty until proven otherwise :^) I am always innocent espically in this game if you want my buddy to claim your welcome to ask him. |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Jan 25, 2018 8:52 PM
#1230
abhutrash said: Shinichi-Kun said: I mean, if you are town, you wouldn't be lying about being a mason...right?abhutrash said: RE1031 said: Was typing out a response to argue against this, then realized I actually agree with you, in that the other mason actually shouldn't claim. At worst case scenario, Shin gets lynched Day 2 and flips Town, basically confirming that there is another mason. Said mason can hide out and really help in late game. That being said, I still think a Day 2 Shin lynch without a Mason confirmation would be a mistake. If things stay as they are, a Day 3 lynch seems obvious, but as of now, a Shin lynch is too hasty. Especially when we have other people to suspect.Ruu said: I just feel super uncomfortable with this. On one hand, if he's mafia, then yeah, we want his partner to claim so they can be put on the peek list to see if they're both really town. On the other, having a secret mason can be really helpful especially late game because that's one person we know not to lynch.abhutrash said: Also, whoever is Shin's supposed mason partner should really step up. The claim is getting less and less convincing by the hour. +1 Also, even if someone else claims, what do we do then? Do we believe the claim or is there going to be some way of testing it? My question is basically how would a partner coming out to claim change whether we believe it or not. Only thing that would complicate this approach would be if Tainted actually was the other mason. I doubt it, but its still is a possibility. Did i reason something wrong? How does me dieing and flipping town confirm the existence of another mason? I just curious seeing as how my role isnt show on death. I mean people can argue all day for me to out my partner but ultiamtely the decision is up to them not me. Also, I agree that you have no responsibility to out your mason friend, that's on them. wisp is the one saying you should. I aint lieing I am a mason Not just wisp a few others are as well |
Jan 25, 2018 8:54 PM
#1231
This is some classic sibling rivalry we're being treated to tonight. Got the popcorn out and I'm having a swell ol time xD |
Jan 25, 2018 8:54 PM
#1232
lastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: i dont think ur understanding what I am saying... let me reiterate this for you...Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: I dont wanna give anyone free clears is all, outside of pokeit its hard to see some people as town maybe riku if hes not lieing obviously So who is scum for you? Who do you want to lynch today? ill get back to you on this, but a slight answer is that ur one of the people i suspect. YOU HAVE 24 HOURS TO PROVE TO ME YOU ARE NOT SCUM, OR else YOU WILL FACE MY FURY... ok? ik what ur role is so i aint scared lol, i know exactly what ur capable of if my assumption is correct. But your just calling my posts shit and not even properly replying to the things I say yet u want me to defend myself get the fuck out of here with that shit. |
Jan 25, 2018 8:55 PM
#1233
lastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: you do that yourself... cause your posts can be just as bad as Ruu's most of the timelastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: i dont think ur role is scum aligned, i think you are scum and that role claim is a lie, I think you are scum because of the way you've been playing this game...lastwhisper31 said: vote: Shin u have 24 hours to prove to me you are town, w/o using your claim... @shinichi-kun More curious to know why u think i am scum and why u think my role is scum aligned. my thats my role, and i dont feel like i am playing any differently your just trying to turn me into to something i am not is all. thats fine by me, if people want to vote me cause i always sound scummy go right ahead. |
Jan 25, 2018 8:56 PM
#1234
Shinichi-Kun said: Then, a lynch and town flip would confirm there was another mason.abhutrash said: Shinichi-Kun said: abhutrash said: RE1031 said: Was typing out a response to argue against this, then realized I actually agree with you, in that the other mason actually shouldn't claim. At worst case scenario, Shin gets lynched Day 2 and flips Town, basically confirming that there is another mason. Said mason can hide out and really help in late game. That being said, I still think a Day 2 Shin lynch without a Mason confirmation would be a mistake. If things stay as they are, a Day 3 lynch seems obvious, but as of now, a Shin lynch is too hasty. Especially when we have other people to suspect.Ruu said: I just feel super uncomfortable with this. On one hand, if he's mafia, then yeah, we want his partner to claim so they can be put on the peek list to see if they're both really town. On the other, having a secret mason can be really helpful especially late game because that's one person we know not to lynch.abhutrash said: Also, whoever is Shin's supposed mason partner should really step up. The claim is getting less and less convincing by the hour. +1 Also, even if someone else claims, what do we do then? Do we believe the claim or is there going to be some way of testing it? My question is basically how would a partner coming out to claim change whether we believe it or not. Only thing that would complicate this approach would be if Tainted actually was the other mason. I doubt it, but its still is a possibility. Did i reason something wrong? How does me dieing and flipping town confirm the existence of another mason? I just curious seeing as how my role isnt show on death. I mean people can argue all day for me to out my partner but ultiamtely the decision is up to them not me. Also, I agree that you have no responsibility to out your mason friend, that's on them. wisp is the one saying you should. I aint lieing I am a mason Not just wisp a few others are as well Shinichi-Kun said: Like, wut?How does me dieing and flipping town confirm the existence of another mason? |
Jan 25, 2018 8:56 PM
#1235
Shinichi-Kun said: cause ur posts are that bad, its like ur choking... I could go and point out all your contradictions, and prove to everyone that you are lying when u say u've never fake claimed before...lastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: I dont wanna give anyone free clears is all, outside of pokeit its hard to see some people as town maybe riku if hes not lieing obviously So who is scum for you? Who do you want to lynch today? ill get back to you on this, but a slight answer is that ur one of the people i suspect. YOU HAVE 24 HOURS TO PROVE TO ME YOU ARE NOT SCUM, OR else YOU WILL FACE MY FURY... ok? ik what ur role is so i aint scared lol, i know exactly what ur capable of if my assumption is correct. But your just calling my posts shit and not even properly replying to the things I say yet u want me to defend myself get the fuck out of here with that shit. |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Jan 25, 2018 8:56 PM
#1236
Karote said: lastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: Ruu said: abhutrash said: Ruu said: A second person claiming mason wouldn't fully confirm for town tho. For all we know, there might not be masons in the game.lastwhisper31 said: RE1031 said: I dont agree with everything Ruu does or says, but I do agree after thinking about it, that masons claims are a pretty good safety net for scum, and meta wise I've seen some of Chad role claims, and even with the day phase rolling to an end, it still doesn't feel like a town role claim. I do agree, having a secret mason would be helpful, but with chad being consistently scummy it wouldnt even matter, and whose to say that when the other person claims, that he isnt just as scummy either, its not like when he claims, that all of their scuminess will just be gone with the wind. and we look at how they interact outside their private chat, and who the other player is could say a lot... I understand why you feel it would be better, but in the case of Chad, like I said, he has 24 hours from that post this afternoon to give me a reason hes not scum... Ruu said: I just feel super uncomfortable with this. On one hand, if he's mafia, then yeah, we want his partner to claim so they can be put on the peek list to see if they're both really town. On the other, having a secret mason can be really helpful especially late game because that's one person we know not to lynch.abhutrash said: Also, whoever is Shin's supposed mason partner should really step up. The claim is getting less and less convincing by the hour. +1 Also, even if someone else claims, what do we do then? Do we believe the claim or is there going to be some way of testing it? My question is basically how would a partner coming out to claim change whether we believe it or not. the bolded part is why I want him to claim. If his partner is someone I was townreading I will rethink the whole thing and might help me see his posts in a different way. I think I have an idea on who this misterious partner could be and I'm waiting for them to confirm it. Explain to me why a secret mason is better than two confirmed townies. @RE1031 I think you are contradicting yourself with this post and the previous one. Why I want Shin's partner to claim? - I think Shin is mafia and he is fake claiming - if his partner confirms his claim we might get two confirmed townies (or we could find another mafia, it all depends) - what's better? to lynch Shin now and find out his alignment and if he is town confirmed his claim or get two confirmed townies and lynch scum thanks to a better town block? -One thing i want to understand since its been bothering me alot, why do u believe its a fake claim and that I aint just scum mason? -I dont want 2 confirmed townies I want mafia to risk shooting my mason buddy -Ur already under a bias assumption because ur assuming if I am town then my buddy is town which honestly shouldnt be the case. IM FUCKING DEAD ROFL Idk what he's defending against anymore Idk why kyle pinged you here, and idk at this point its hard to defend against a endless tunnel |
Jan 25, 2018 8:56 PM
#1237
lastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: you are such a liar.......................... holy shitlastwhisper31 said: So not only do u believe i am lieing about my claim which i aint u have some biased belief my mason buddy is scum with me?lol, no, I dont think ur mason, so you have no buddy... your scum partner doesnt need to be mason to claim mason with you... thats my point, stop acting like you dont understand what I am saying I am a mason and my buddy is clearly real I dont fake claim, i aint confident enough to come up with fake claims idk if I can even wait 24 hours... Just use your ability then |
Jan 25, 2018 8:57 PM
#1238
abhutrash said: no roles on death, so technically hes correct in that aspect, but i dont like this sort of AtE coming from at all...Shinichi-Kun said: Then, a lynch and town flip would confirm there was another mason.abhutrash said: Shinichi-Kun said: I mean, if you are town, you wouldn't be lying about being a mason...right?abhutrash said: RE1031 said: Was typing out a response to argue against this, then realized I actually agree with you, in that the other mason actually shouldn't claim. At worst case scenario, Shin gets lynched Day 2 and flips Town, basically confirming that there is another mason. Said mason can hide out and really help in late game. That being said, I still think a Day 2 Shin lynch without a Mason confirmation would be a mistake. If things stay as they are, a Day 3 lynch seems obvious, but as of now, a Shin lynch is too hasty. Especially when we have other people to suspect.Ruu said: I just feel super uncomfortable with this. On one hand, if he's mafia, then yeah, we want his partner to claim so they can be put on the peek list to see if they're both really town. On the other, having a secret mason can be really helpful especially late game because that's one person we know not to lynch.abhutrash said: Also, whoever is Shin's supposed mason partner should really step up. The claim is getting less and less convincing by the hour. +1 Also, even if someone else claims, what do we do then? Do we believe the claim or is there going to be some way of testing it? My question is basically how would a partner coming out to claim change whether we believe it or not. Only thing that would complicate this approach would be if Tainted actually was the other mason. I doubt it, but its still is a possibility. Did i reason something wrong? How does me dieing and flipping town confirm the existence of another mason? I just curious seeing as how my role isnt show on death. I mean people can argue all day for me to out my partner but ultiamtely the decision is up to them not me. Also, I agree that you have no responsibility to out your mason friend, that's on them. wisp is the one saying you should. I aint lieing I am a mason Not just wisp a few others are as well Shinichi-Kun said: Like, wut?How does me dieing and flipping town confirm the existence of another mason? |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Jan 25, 2018 8:57 PM
#1239
Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: lastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: liar............................................... such a liar....................................... burn it at the sakeRuu said: lastwhisper31 said: Ruu said: tbh whats your opinion on both their EoD claims? Im curious...this thread is so dead... @abhutrash @Shinichi-Kun are you gonna keep your votes on Togs? What do you guys think of logic? I think abhu's claim is more believable than Chad's. He thought he was had died so there was no need to fake claim. Masons, on the other hand, is a great fake claim that has been used by the mafia. I want to know who is this famous partner of his. That will tell us if this claim is true or not. I dont fake claim i suck at it, i am the kind of person even if i am sucm roleblocker ill just claim roleblocker an pray. This is my role and I am town, I didnt want to even have to claim but if i was going to i wouldnt have done it at the last minute. I thought doing it an hour before phase change gave people plenty of oppurutunity took look over it. Find a game where i made up a claim u will never find one cause i dont fake claim Doesn't mean you can't improvise and make up claim here. Again i ddint cause i am a mason lmfao, like holy shit people really dont like me claiming. |
Jan 25, 2018 8:57 PM
#1240
lastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: you want me to find the game(s), do you really wanna go there? cause there aint no going back after that... and if your town, you dug your own gravelastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: liar............................................... such a liar....................................... burn it at the sakeRuu said: lastwhisper31 said: Ruu said: tbh whats your opinion on both their EoD claims? Im curious...this thread is so dead... @abhutrash @Shinichi-Kun are you gonna keep your votes on Togs? What do you guys think of logic? I think abhu's claim is more believable than Chad's. He thought he was had died so there was no need to fake claim. Masons, on the other hand, is a great fake claim that has been used by the mafia. I want to know who is this famous partner of his. That will tell us if this claim is true or not. I dont fake claim i suck at it, i am the kind of person even if i am sucm roleblocker ill just claim roleblocker an pray. This is my role and I am town, I didnt want to even have to claim but if i was going to i wouldnt have done it at the last minute. I thought doing it an hour before phase change gave people plenty of oppurutunity took look over it. Find a game where i made up a claim u will never find one cause i dont fake claim U seem to think i fake claim, but in reality i don't |
Jan 25, 2018 8:58 PM
#1241
Shinichi-Kun said: I pinged him because he changed votes to Iron... and I wanted him to come backKarote said: lastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: THESE POSTS ARE SO BAD LOL.... @karote get ur ass back over hereRuu said: abhutrash said: Ruu said: A second person claiming mason wouldn't fully confirm for town tho. For all we know, there might not be masons in the game.lastwhisper31 said: RE1031 said: I dont agree with everything Ruu does or says, but I do agree after thinking about it, that masons claims are a pretty good safety net for scum, and meta wise I've seen some of Chad role claims, and even with the day phase rolling to an end, it still doesn't feel like a town role claim. I do agree, having a secret mason would be helpful, but with chad being consistently scummy it wouldnt even matter, and whose to say that when the other person claims, that he isnt just as scummy either, its not like when he claims, that all of their scuminess will just be gone with the wind. and we look at how they interact outside their private chat, and who the other player is could say a lot... I understand why you feel it would be better, but in the case of Chad, like I said, he has 24 hours from that post this afternoon to give me a reason hes not scum... Ruu said: I just feel super uncomfortable with this. On one hand, if he's mafia, then yeah, we want his partner to claim so they can be put on the peek list to see if they're both really town. On the other, having a secret mason can be really helpful especially late game because that's one person we know not to lynch.abhutrash said: Also, whoever is Shin's supposed mason partner should really step up. The claim is getting less and less convincing by the hour. +1 Also, even if someone else claims, what do we do then? Do we believe the claim or is there going to be some way of testing it? My question is basically how would a partner coming out to claim change whether we believe it or not. the bolded part is why I want him to claim. If his partner is someone I was townreading I will rethink the whole thing and might help me see his posts in a different way. I think I have an idea on who this misterious partner could be and I'm waiting for them to confirm it. Explain to me why a secret mason is better than two confirmed townies. @RE1031 I think you are contradicting yourself with this post and the previous one. Why I want Shin's partner to claim? - I think Shin is mafia and he is fake claiming - if his partner confirms his claim we might get two confirmed townies (or we could find another mafia, it all depends) - what's better? to lynch Shin now and find out his alignment and if he is town confirmed his claim or get two confirmed townies and lynch scum thanks to a better town block? -One thing i want to understand since its been bothering me alot, why do u believe its a fake claim and that I aint just scum mason? -I dont want 2 confirmed townies I want mafia to risk shooting my mason buddy -Ur already under a bias assumption because ur assuming if I am town then my buddy is town which honestly shouldnt be the case. IM FUCKING DEAD ROFL Idk what he's defending against anymore Idk why kyle pinged you here, and idk at this point its hard to defend against a endless tunnel |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Jan 25, 2018 8:59 PM
#1242
abhutrash said: Shinichi-Kun said: Then, a lynch and town flip would confirm there was another mason.abhutrash said: Shinichi-Kun said: I mean, if you are town, you wouldn't be lying about being a mason...right?abhutrash said: RE1031 said: Was typing out a response to argue against this, then realized I actually agree with you, in that the other mason actually shouldn't claim. At worst case scenario, Shin gets lynched Day 2 and flips Town, basically confirming that there is another mason. Said mason can hide out and really help in late game. That being said, I still think a Day 2 Shin lynch without a Mason confirmation would be a mistake. If things stay as they are, a Day 3 lynch seems obvious, but as of now, a Shin lynch is too hasty. Especially when we have other people to suspect.Ruu said: I just feel super uncomfortable with this. On one hand, if he's mafia, then yeah, we want his partner to claim so they can be put on the peek list to see if they're both really town. On the other, having a secret mason can be really helpful especially late game because that's one person we know not to lynch.abhutrash said: Also, whoever is Shin's supposed mason partner should really step up. The claim is getting less and less convincing by the hour. +1 Also, even if someone else claims, what do we do then? Do we believe the claim or is there going to be some way of testing it? My question is basically how would a partner coming out to claim change whether we believe it or not. Only thing that would complicate this approach would be if Tainted actually was the other mason. I doubt it, but its still is a possibility. Did i reason something wrong? How does me dieing and flipping town confirm the existence of another mason? I just curious seeing as how my role isnt show on death. I mean people can argue all day for me to out my partner but ultiamtely the decision is up to them not me. Also, I agree that you have no responsibility to out your mason friend, that's on them. wisp is the one saying you should. I aint lieing I am a mason Not just wisp a few others are as well Shinichi-Kun said: Like, wut?How does me dieing and flipping town confirm the existence of another mason? Its a serious question tho, is it not? You guys have no reason to believe i am mason so i am speaking metaphorically is all |
Jan 25, 2018 8:59 PM
#1243
Shinichi-Kun said: Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: this stuff. lemme look some more edit--why didnt anyone question her again? smh eh. Im back to square 1 Karote said: And why didn't you? : D I thought she played like always, sharing her thoughts time to time and playing lowkey. Didn't felt anything worthy to attack her for. Shinichi said: I mean u could have always pressured her all of us could have instead of just letting her hide away. Idk, yurkin is that type of player you don't really notice until you need sort out PoE, lmao. Shinichi-Kun said: Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: Pokeit said: Are masons always town-alligned? Or is there a possibility that one of them is scum? Not always but i aint sure if thats considered a bastard role if its done like that. Why aren't you outing your other mason? why should I? U want me to narrow down the targets for mafia to nk? Why are you so worried about that? lol It narrows down the PoE and it hurts mafia more anyway if town has 2 more confirmed townies. We benefit more than scum does. Not true cause i cant confirm the alignment of my buddy only myself, my role pm says nothing about my buddy having to be town. I dont want to give a false premise and i def dont want to risk confining my partner to death. you do realise you are basically admiting your role is bs? masons know that they are both town, that's the whole point! Having someone you know, you can trust! The roles that can have different alignments are neighbours or lovers. The most obvious power of a Masonry is the mutual confirmation of multiple players as Town. Alignment: Pro-town |
Jan 25, 2018 8:59 PM
#1244
lastwhisper31 said: Yeah, I know no roles on death, but if he actually is a town, I have idea why he'd be lying about his mason claim.abhutrash said: no roles on death, so technically hes correct in that aspect, but i dont like this sort of AtE coming from at all...Shinichi-Kun said: abhutrash said: Shinichi-Kun said: I mean, if you are town, you wouldn't be lying about being a mason...right?abhutrash said: RE1031 said: Was typing out a response to argue against this, then realized I actually agree with you, in that the other mason actually shouldn't claim. At worst case scenario, Shin gets lynched Day 2 and flips Town, basically confirming that there is another mason. Said mason can hide out and really help in late game. That being said, I still think a Day 2 Shin lynch without a Mason confirmation would be a mistake. If things stay as they are, a Day 3 lynch seems obvious, but as of now, a Shin lynch is too hasty. Especially when we have other people to suspect.Ruu said: I just feel super uncomfortable with this. On one hand, if he's mafia, then yeah, we want his partner to claim so they can be put on the peek list to see if they're both really town. On the other, having a secret mason can be really helpful especially late game because that's one person we know not to lynch.abhutrash said: Also, whoever is Shin's supposed mason partner should really step up. The claim is getting less and less convincing by the hour. +1 Also, even if someone else claims, what do we do then? Do we believe the claim or is there going to be some way of testing it? My question is basically how would a partner coming out to claim change whether we believe it or not. Only thing that would complicate this approach would be if Tainted actually was the other mason. I doubt it, but its still is a possibility. Did i reason something wrong? How does me dieing and flipping town confirm the existence of another mason? I just curious seeing as how my role isnt show on death. I mean people can argue all day for me to out my partner but ultiamtely the decision is up to them not me. Also, I agree that you have no responsibility to out your mason friend, that's on them. wisp is the one saying you should. I aint lieing I am a mason Not just wisp a few others are as well Shinichi-Kun said: How does me dieing and flipping town confirm the existence of another mason? |
Jan 25, 2018 9:00 PM
#1245
lastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: cause ur posts are that bad, its like ur choking... I could go and point out all your contradictions, and prove to everyone that you are lying when u say u've never fake claimed before...lastwhisper31 said: Shinichi-Kun said: i dont think ur understanding what I am saying... let me reiterate this for you...Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: I dont wanna give anyone free clears is all, outside of pokeit its hard to see some people as town maybe riku if hes not lieing obviously So who is scum for you? Who do you want to lynch today? ill get back to you on this, but a slight answer is that ur one of the people i suspect. YOU HAVE 24 HOURS TO PROVE TO ME YOU ARE NOT SCUM, OR else YOU WILL FACE MY FURY... ok? ik what ur role is so i aint scared lol, i know exactly what ur capable of if my assumption is correct. But your just calling my posts shit and not even properly replying to the things I say yet u want me to defend myself get the fuck out of here with that shit. Go ahead lmfao, i contradict myself all the time as either alignment |
Jan 25, 2018 9:01 PM
#1246
Ruu said: yes and no... it kinda matters on what the Mods, consider bastard... some mods think deviating to much from the norm is bastard, and some only think role changing abilities are bastard, like cults, and etc... but ya chad is choking right now...Shinichi-Kun said: Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: this stuff. lemme look some more edit--why didnt anyone question her again? smh eh. Im back to square 1 Karote said: And why didn't you? : D I thought she played like always, sharing her thoughts time to time and playing lowkey. Didn't felt anything worthy to attack her for. Shinichi said: I mean u could have always pressured her all of us could have instead of just letting her hide away. Idk, yurkin is that type of player you don't really notice until you need sort out PoE, lmao. Shinichi-Kun said: Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: Pokeit said: Are masons always town-alligned? Or is there a possibility that one of them is scum? Not always but i aint sure if thats considered a bastard role if its done like that. Why aren't you outing your other mason? why should I? U want me to narrow down the targets for mafia to nk? Why are you so worried about that? lol It narrows down the PoE and it hurts mafia more anyway if town has 2 more confirmed townies. We benefit more than scum does. Not true cause i cant confirm the alignment of my buddy only myself, my role pm says nothing about my buddy having to be town. I dont want to give a false premise and i def dont want to risk confining my partner to death. you do realise you are basically admiting your role is bs? masons know that they are both town, that's the whole point! Having someone you know, you can trust! The roles that can have different alignments are neighbours or lovers. The most obvious power of a Masonry is the mutual confirmation of multiple players as Town. Alignment: Pro-town |
blinddate she was never awake even with her eyes wide open never where she longed to be and if you’d meet her just know you were on a blind date with a dreamer |
Jan 25, 2018 9:01 PM
#1247
abhutrash said: This is some classic sibling rivalry we're being treated to tonight. Got the popcorn out and I'm having a swell ol time xD same lol |
Jan 25, 2018 9:02 PM
#1248
Ruu said: Shinichi-Kun said: Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: this stuff. lemme look some more edit--why didnt anyone question her again? smh eh. Im back to square 1 Karote said: And why didn't you? : D I thought she played like always, sharing her thoughts time to time and playing lowkey. Didn't felt anything worthy to attack her for. Shinichi said: I mean u could have always pressured her all of us could have instead of just letting her hide away. Idk, yurkin is that type of player you don't really notice until you need sort out PoE, lmao. Shinichi-Kun said: Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: Pokeit said: Are masons always town-alligned? Or is there a possibility that one of them is scum? Not always but i aint sure if thats considered a bastard role if its done like that. Why aren't you outing your other mason? why should I? U want me to narrow down the targets for mafia to nk? Why are you so worried about that? lol It narrows down the PoE and it hurts mafia more anyway if town has 2 more confirmed townies. We benefit more than scum does. Not true cause i cant confirm the alignment of my buddy only myself, my role pm says nothing about my buddy having to be town. I dont want to give a false premise and i def dont want to risk confining my partner to death. you do realise you are basically admiting your role is bs? masons know that they are both town, that's the whole point! Having someone you know, you can trust! The roles that can have different alignments are neighbours or lovers. The most obvious power of a Masonry is the mutual confirmation of multiple players as Town. Alignment: Pro-town My role says nothing of the sorts, its just says i have a secret chat with my mason partner. You are able to externally communicate with your other Mason partner at a secret club |
Jan 25, 2018 9:02 PM
#1249
abhutrash said: I have *no* idea why he'd be lying. Goddammit, I can't type right now...lastwhisper31 said: Yeah, I know no roles on death, but if he actually is a town, I have idea why he'd be lying about his mason claim.abhutrash said: Shinichi-Kun said: Then, a lynch and town flip would confirm there was another mason.abhutrash said: Shinichi-Kun said: I mean, if you are town, you wouldn't be lying about being a mason...right?abhutrash said: RE1031 said: Was typing out a response to argue against this, then realized I actually agree with you, in that the other mason actually shouldn't claim. At worst case scenario, Shin gets lynched Day 2 and flips Town, basically confirming that there is another mason. Said mason can hide out and really help in late game. That being said, I still think a Day 2 Shin lynch without a Mason confirmation would be a mistake. If things stay as they are, a Day 3 lynch seems obvious, but as of now, a Shin lynch is too hasty. Especially when we have other people to suspect.Ruu said: I just feel super uncomfortable with this. On one hand, if he's mafia, then yeah, we want his partner to claim so they can be put on the peek list to see if they're both really town. On the other, having a secret mason can be really helpful especially late game because that's one person we know not to lynch.abhutrash said: Also, whoever is Shin's supposed mason partner should really step up. The claim is getting less and less convincing by the hour. +1 Also, even if someone else claims, what do we do then? Do we believe the claim or is there going to be some way of testing it? My question is basically how would a partner coming out to claim change whether we believe it or not. Only thing that would complicate this approach would be if Tainted actually was the other mason. I doubt it, but its still is a possibility. Did i reason something wrong? How does me dieing and flipping town confirm the existence of another mason? I just curious seeing as how my role isnt show on death. I mean people can argue all day for me to out my partner but ultiamtely the decision is up to them not me. Also, I agree that you have no responsibility to out your mason friend, that's on them. wisp is the one saying you should. I aint lieing I am a mason Not just wisp a few others are as well Shinichi-Kun said: Like, wut?How does me dieing and flipping town confirm the existence of another mason? |
Jan 25, 2018 9:02 PM
#1250
lastwhisper31 said: Ruu said: yes and no... it kinda matters on what the Mods, consider bastard... some mods think deviating to much from the norm is bastard, and some only think role changing abilities are bastard, like cults, and etc... but ya chad is choking right now...Shinichi-Kun said: Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: this stuff. lemme look some more edit--why didnt anyone question her again? smh eh. Im back to square 1 Karote said: And why didn't you? : D I thought she played like always, sharing her thoughts time to time and playing lowkey. Didn't felt anything worthy to attack her for. Shinichi said: I mean u could have always pressured her all of us could have instead of just letting her hide away. Idk, yurkin is that type of player you don't really notice until you need sort out PoE, lmao. Shinichi-Kun said: Karote said: Shinichi-Kun said: Pokeit said: Are masons always town-alligned? Or is there a possibility that one of them is scum? Not always but i aint sure if thats considered a bastard role if its done like that. Why aren't you outing your other mason? why should I? U want me to narrow down the targets for mafia to nk? Why are you so worried about that? lol It narrows down the PoE and it hurts mafia more anyway if town has 2 more confirmed townies. We benefit more than scum does. Not true cause i cant confirm the alignment of my buddy only myself, my role pm says nothing about my buddy having to be town. I dont want to give a false premise and i def dont want to risk confining my partner to death. you do realise you are basically admiting your role is bs? masons know that they are both town, that's the whole point! Having someone you know, you can trust! The roles that can have different alignments are neighbours or lovers. The most obvious power of a Masonry is the mutual confirmation of multiple players as Town. Alignment: Pro-town but lke you guys told me before this is not a bastard setup so.... |
More topics from this board
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8752 |
by Aswin_Ash
»»
Jan 23, 11:52 AM |
|
» Chat Thread ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Fo - Jul 10, 2014 |
3741 |
by Jackrito
»»
Jan 11, 3:55 PM |
|
» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Lambtron - May 15, 2018 |
1161 |
by Jackrito
»»
Jan 9, 8:12 AM |
|
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2870 |
by Jackrito
»»
Jan 8, 11:22 AM |
|
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated MEMBER Posts! v1 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SoulEaterQUEEN - Mar 26, 2016 |
1990 |
by Serafos
»»
Aug 17, 2024 9:42 PM |