Toradora is a very quintessential romantic comedy that is the type of anime that just gets people into anime. Not only is this romantic comedy fun to watch, the addition of classic tropes, archetypes, and cultural references make it a paradigm of Japanese school romance anime. In addition, its characters depict an emotional realism that many adolescents confront when growing up. Some of our most formative moments were when we young and in love.
The anime centers upon the social-emotional development of teenagers enveloped in a love triangle… which itself develops into a love polygon-of-many-sides. It focuses on loniness, abandonment, and the love of being loved with the main character saying “having someone saying you're okay and being needed by that person...It was nice to have someone like that." Sometimes people are in love, sometimes people love the thought of being loved, and sometimes people experience both at the same time.
The anime also delves into dreams vs. reality - that sometimes we overly idolize and fall for someone that isn’t honestly a best match while at the same time failing to spot true love in front of our faces. The plot shows what it means to let go of expectations and desires to come to terms with what is best, natural, and true. Sometimes we learn this the hard way as another main character said “if you trip while running down a hallway, you'll get a nosebleed. If you trip in life, you cry."
Toradora was such an introduction to tropes, archetypes, love-triangles, and school romance for so many nascent anime fans that it became influential for getting people into anime.